Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Second referendum is more likely in disputed areas, Kirkuk Governor suggests

By Rudaw 18/8/2017
Kirkuk Governor Najmaldin Karim speaks to Rudaw TV on August 16, 2017 in Erbil. Photo: Rudaw TV
Kirkuk Governor Najmaldin Karim speaks to Rudaw TV on August 16, 2017 in Erbil. Photo: Rudaw TV
ERBIL, Kurdistan Region – The governor of Kirkuk has said in very clear terms that the independence referendum that will be conducted by the Kurdistan Region this September will not determine the future of the disputed areas as defined by Article 140 of the Iraqi constitution.
President Masoud Barzani and Kurdistan’s top diplomat Falah Mustafa had each earlier hinted at a second referendum in these areas, called Kurdistani by Erbil but claimed by both Erbil and Baghdad.
Governor Najmaldin Karim, who along with President Barzani is expected to meet with different components of Kirkuk before the September referendum, including Turkmens and Arabs, said that the September vote will change nothing, especially in Kirkuk.
“There will be no changes on the 26th [of September] when people wake up. The process had finished and votes would then be counted. I am sure the vote will be yes for Kurdistan’s independence,” Karim told Rudaw on Wednesday in an interview that will be released later in full. 
“But with regard to Kirkuk in particular, we are committed by Article 140. Our Provincial Council sent a letter to Baghdad in June, after the [Kurdistan] flag was raised, calling for Article 140 to be implemented so that the referendum is held,” Karim continued.

The acting head of the the  Provincial Council in Kirkuk Rebwar Talabani said they received a response to the letter by Baghdad which stipulated that they are unable to hold the referendum. 
Article 140 concerns the disputed areas. It stipulated Baghdad take a series of steps to reverse the process of Arabization practiced by the former Iraqi regime in Kirkuk and other places such as Nineveh, and eventually hold a referendum that gives the people in these areas the option of joining the Kurdistan Region or remaining with Baghdad. 
Article 140 passed its 2007 deadline without being implemented.
Governor Karim said they are committed to Article 140 so long as they are part of Iraq.
“We have given the guarantee [to other components] that the future of Kirkuk will not be determined by the referendum. The people of Kirkuk will decide the future of Kirkuk, i.e. the Kurds, Turkmen, Arabs, Chaldeans and Assyrians. There is Article 140, and we will be committed to the Iraqi constitution so long as we are a part of Iraq. Article 140 encompasses places outside the (Kurdistan) Region, the places we consider part of Kurdistan.”
Governor Karim said that Kirkuk should have a special status when it joins the Kurdistan Region, or a future independent Kurdistan, calling on the Kurdistan Region to reassure that other components are dealt with like “partners,” and that their national and cultural rights such as education are protected.
He called for a transitional period, at least for the first 10 years, when these components can be given deputy positions within Kurdistan’s presidency, parliament and the government.
After this period, it may be possible that an Arab or Turkmen, through election, becomes the president of Kurdistan, or holds other senior positions.
The minorities in Kurdistan have 11 seats reserved through a quota system of the Kurdistan parliament's 111 seats; their languages and religions are recognized and protected by law.
There are Kurds, Arabs, Turkmens as well as Yezidis and Christians, among others, who are living in these areas, with some showing support for the referendum, while other have decided to express their opposition.
The Iraqi Turkmen Front, the largest for the Turkmens in Iraq, and a Christian armed group that is incorporated within the mainly-Shiite Hashd al-Shaabi, the Babylon Movement, have separately asked the Kurdish government to exclude their areas from the independence referendum.
There are some Turkmen and Christian parties who are part of the Kurdish High Referendum Council who called for the referendum earlier in June, and some Arab tribes have said they are for the referendum in some areas in Nineveh that are under the control of the Peshmerga forces.
Asked whether the people in the disputed areas will have an option to say whether they want to be part of Kurdistan or not, President Barzani told American Foreign Policy magazine in June that they would not have the option in the September vote, but added “If they need another referendum, then maybe after that.”
Barzani said then that they will respect the will of people in the disputed areas in either case.



Pliny The Kurd | 18/8/2017
Iraq has refused to apply the article 140 of its constitution . Those territories were taken from Kurds by Saddam with killings and genocide. Moreover Iraq has failed to defend those territories as they were invaded by the Islamic State. The Kurds have retaken their lands from the terror I.S. with peshmergas blood and there is no need whatsoever to wait for Iraq to implement that already outdated article.The 25 September referendum will bring the definitive legal solution to the so-called disputed areas.
Muraz Adzhoev | 18/8/2017
"The acting head of the Provincial Council in Kirkuk Rebwar Talabani said they received a response to the letter by Baghdad which stipulated that they are unable to hold the referendum", obviously because Iraqi government has never been committed to the Constitution and especially to its Article 140 for 12 years already. What's going on there in Kirkuk and in Erbil now? If there is really the reasonable need for secondary referendums in some areas, including Kirkuk, on their administrative statuses, then they must be conducted certainly only in and within independent Southern Kurdistan after the general referendum on 25.09.2017. Do not create so much complicated situation, which could mislead and confuse the absolute majority of the People and the Peshmerga army forces. Iraqi Arab Islamic federation is dead. What Constitution and Article 140 of this failed state are you talking about? The whole world and the whole Kurdish nation have been waiting for the Declaration of reintegration and independence of Southern Kurdistan. All other referendums on different issues, particularly on a draft constitution (statehood, including matters on statuses of regions and provinces) should be held in sovereignly independent (democratic and secular) Southern Kurdistan. Go on, postpone the general referendum on reintegration, on independence of Southern Kurdistan, if you still think you are a part of deadly failed Iraq, and how will you look into millions of eyes of the People and the Peshmerga army forces, those who trusted you sovereign power and right.
Hawar | 19/8/2017
In case of Referendum all kurds Nations must be united. please do not make it complicate and difficult like every other nations in this world lets be united and say YES to have our proud Kuristan Flag add it to the United Nations flags as one Brave Commander Mahmmood Sangavy said no matter who call for independence we all should support independence.
FAUthman | 19/8/2017
President Barzani had said: "only territories where the people overwhelmingly want to be part of Kurdistan need to take part in the referendum and could become part of an independent Kurdistan. Others can make that decision for themselves later on. This is a reasonable position and president Barzani makes sense and shows astute leadership in taking that position!

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Benny | 4/23/2018 1:12:42 AM
Soon or later USA and Israel and some European countries will attack Iran and that government must be replace to a democracy government . That is the...
Non kurd | 4/24/2018 4:47:41 AM
Iran is a third world toilet run by corrupt terrorists. If they resume their nuke program, their dismal economy will turn even worse resulting in...
Iran threatens to 'vigorously' resume enrichment if US quits deal
| 22/4/2018 | (2)
Reckoning | 4/22/2018 7:10:31 PM
Why is the media always telling half true. Because all those innocent people that are kidnappende by Turkish SS corps at least most of them are...
Thomas | 4/24/2018 3:44:49 AM
None of this would happen if Kurds stopped betraying each other. The most recent one is PUK betraying on Kirkuk, Kurds lost the thousands of years...
Turkey jails Kurdish teacher with baby on terror charge
| 21/4/2018 | (10)
Y.E | 4/23/2018 11:52:52 PM
This seems quite backward and generally retarded. What does it matter if he kissed the poster? Why were the families and tribes involved? Why that...
Kissing female Iraqi candidate’s poster costs $84,000
| 23/4/2018 | (1)
Non kurd | 4/19/2018 7:33:32 PM
The barbarians ruling Iran must be overthrown asap.
Outsider | 4/23/2018 11:00:08 PM
I ask myself, what is the YPG doing with terrorists? Look at first into your own "judiciary" before you complain about others...
UN rights experts condemn death sentence of Kurd in Iran
| 19/4/2018 | (2)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

'Gap in perceptions' threatens wider Middle East war 5 hours ago |

'Gap in perceptions' threatens wider Middle East war

"Iran has never threatened to initiate conflict more
Lebanese PM, Iraqi FM implore Europe to assist in Syrian solution 9 hours ago |

Lebanese PM, Iraqi FM implore Europe to assist in Syrian solution

The Iraqi FM addressed recent allegations of a more
0.734 seconds