Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Referendum illegitimate without parliamentary act, says speaker

By Rudaw 24/8/2017
This file photo shows Kurdistan parliament speaker Yousif Mohammed addresses a conference in Erbil in August 2015. Photo: Rudaw/Farzin Hassan
This file photo shows Kurdistan parliament speaker Yousif Mohammed addresses a conference in Erbil in August 2015. Photo: Rudaw/Farzin Hassan
SULAIMANI, Kurdistan Region – The Speaker of the Kurdistan Parliament Yousif Mohammed said next month’s independence referendum will lack “legitimacy” if it goes ahead without an act from the currently suspended parliament.
Mohammed made the remarks during a meeting with civil society members in Sulaimani where he has been practicing some of his powers as parliamentary speaker since the legislature was suspended by the ruling Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) in October 2015.
“The referendum is an important and crucial issue,” Mohammed said, according to a statement from his office. “Without a discussion inside the parliament hall, the referendum will not have legitimacy from a legal point of view.”
He said the issue of the referendum and eventually declaring an independent state of Kurdistan is a “national matter” that should bring all parties together instead of causing “disagreement and feuding” between them.
Mohammed is a member of the Change or Gorran Movement, the second-largest party in the parliament with 24 seats, following the KDP’s 38 seats.
The High Referendum Council that is led by President Masoud Barzani and includes all parties of Kurdistan except for Gorran and the Islamic Group (Komal), decided late last month that the parliament should be reactivated within two weeks, but that never came to pass. Gorran and the KDP are in talks to work out their differences before heading to the parliament.
Gorran released a five-point statement about two weeks ago that mainly called for the parliament to be activated and the referendum postponed until the time is right.
KDP and Gorran most recently met on Monday to discuss issues between them including the referendum, but there are no signs they made any progress. 
Barzani has said that debating the date of the referendum is out of the question. He has remained in power despite the expiration of his term in office two years ago – the main cause of the rift between his KDP and Gorran.
Meanwhile, the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK), the third largest party in Kurdistan, is expected to meet with Gorran to push one last time for a negotiated end to the political stalemate.
The PUK has an alliance with both KDP and Gorran and is a leading party behind the referendum. It said in a statement on Wednesday that it “is insistent on the reactivation of Kurdistan’s parliament before the referendum is held.”
Gorran and Komal have so far refused to attend meetings related to the referendum. The two parties have said that the Kurdistan parliament has to first be reactivated and then pass a law to call the referendum.
Hoshyar Zebari, a senior KDP member, told Rudaw in June that the legitimacy of the Kurdistan referendum is “more valid” if the Kurdistan parliament is active and functioning, but added that they have asked “many legal and international law experts” and all have come to the conclusion that “this is an executive and administrative decision and therefore does not need a law on this matter.”
In October 2015, security forces in Erbil, who are largely under the control of the KDP, blocked the speaker from returning to the capital. 
The KDP also sacked Gorran ministers from the broad-based Kurdistan Regional Government, including the ministers of finance and Peshmerga.


Data pager
Page size:
duroi | 24/8/2017
Goran by calling the upcoming referendum illegitimate is out of line with the aspirations of Kurds. What law of the land has been broken? A large majority of the members of parliament (PUK and KDP) support it, and it is only a matter of a vote by the parliament to rubber-stamp the presidential decree on the matter. Legal scholars can argue that the decree of KRG president as the commander of chief in an emergency war situation (cf Turkey) has even more legitimacy in this case because additionally the disputed regions under the control of Pishmerga have no representatives in the current parliament. It is time to stop pussyfooting around the vote to support the referendum in the parliament and get on with the job.
Gorran is hungry for power | 24/8/2017
No surprise here. The greatest enemy of a Free Kurdistan has always been egoistic corrupt power hungry and myopic Kurdish leadership in various parties. Without these, we would have independence long time ago. Know this, we will never forgive any family that stands in the way of a free Kurdistan. Today or tomorrow, we will have our freedom. If you don't like it, you are free to move to Baghdad
kurt basar | 24/8/2017
Well, Iraq & Syria as well as the Turkish terror state's are illegitimate too. French named Syria after Assyrians & Iraq was gift to the Arabs by the British for to own Baba Gurgur oil field. Kurd's as a children of the cradle of the civilization (Sumerians/Hittite's stock) have every right for the referendum & an independent state, and this shameless Arab bastard migrant is talking about Kurdish referendum to be illegitimate, god help the Kurd's & innocent people.
Salar | 24/8/2017
Everything he said makes sense. You can't decide a referendum without legal status. It's an illegal referendum and no one in the world will recognize it. I don't understand why are we even wasting our time. On September 26, it will be just ink on paper . No more no less .
Tony Montana | 24/8/2017
when the Kurdistan is a state. there should be no Goran or Komala in the gov. they are a pose to this then they should not be apart of it when people decide to be independent

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Leon | 3/24/2019 8:03:06 AM
Sistani is not the governemnt, so get fucked. Iraq should use force to remove him.
Iraqi PM proposes parliament sacks Nineveh governor
| yesterday at 11:47 | (1)
Adam | 3/23/2019 2:49:50 PM
I wander what the Saudi royal family would say.
Gunrash | 3/24/2019 3:10:11 AM
Golan is Israeli just like Kirkuk, Amed, Mehabad and Afrin are Kurdish! Enough with the hypocrisy and selective indignation. UN is a joke.
Trump’s Golan statement draws strong regional condemnation
| yesterday at 08:49 | (4)
Adam | 3/23/2019 2:40:05 PM
Now the west especially America have the duty to reward the Kurds with real protection.
Kurde Canada | 3/24/2019 1:41:08 AM
God is no more with ISIS. They were just being used by him. They were betrayed.
SDF declare ‘total elimination’ of ISIS caliphate
| yesterday at 09:32 | (4)
TerraNova | 3/23/2019 10:02:06 PM
And now you show the world that The United States of America stands by it's allies and dose NOT abandon an ally that sacrificed thousands of brave...
Dutchman | 3/23/2019 11:18:00 PM
Trump is right when he sais that the US together with it's allies defeated ISIS. And it is also good that he wants to continue to work with his...
Trump: ISIS ‘are losers, will always be losers’
| yesterday at 10:58 | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Iraq PM courts Egyptian investment at Cairo summit 5 hours ago |

Iraq PM courts Egyptian investment at Cairo summit

Egyptians "thoroughly understand the difficulties more
Jihadists emerge from tunnels to surrender after ‘caliphate’ falls 7 hours ago |

Jihadists emerge from tunnels to surrender after ‘caliphate’ falls

"Some others could still be hiding inside" more
0.265 seconds