Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Retired US general, colonel see Kurdish independence as right path

By Rudaw 24/9/2017
Retired US Col. Richard Naab and retired Lt. Gen. Jay Garner speak with Rudaw's Shaho Amen on September 24.
Retired US Col. Richard Naab and retired Lt. Gen. Jay Garner speak with Rudaw's Shaho Amen on September 24.
ERBIL, Kurdistan Region — Two retired US military officers with a quarter century’s experience in Kurdistan and Iraq see the Kurdistan Region’s independence vote as a result of Iraqi regimes which have failed Kurds and other minority groups like Sunnis and Christians. 

"They've tried very hard to be a part of the Iraqi government for 14 years now. But that hasn't worked,” said retired US Lt. Gen. Jay Garner.

The White House told the Kurdistan Region to “call off” Monday's referendum, describing it as “particularly provocative and destabilizing” in the disputed areas.

Garner explained his view differs because the self-determinative vote is an example of people expressing “their will and what they want and we should support that because that's the democratic way in doing things."

The general retired in 1997 after having commanded Patriot missile batteries in the Gulf War and coordinated with Kurdish fighters in the early 1990s. After the US invasion in 2003, Garner was named Administrator of the Coalition Provisional Authority before being replaced by Paul Bremer after three weeks in the post.  

"You're having a referendum on independence,” said Garner. “I'm very supportive of that and of the Iraqi Kurdish region becoming independent.”

The American called Kurdistan "probably the most strategic place in the Middle East for us."

Col. Richard Naab was involved in Operation Provide Comfort in 1991 and has previously described US policy as flimsy and said he cried when his country left in 1992.

He told Rudaw that US leaders need to be better informed regarding Kurds and their referendum.

"We have to make sure to reassure them that it's not and geographic, aggressive movement. It's rather giving the Kurds what they should've had from the very beginning — their own land, their own language, their own money, their own passports. That's what every Kurd aspires to have. That for us seems to be a no brainer, it should be,” he said.

Hours after Naab’s remarks, Iran closed its airspace with the Kurdistan Region.

"They can handle the Iranians better than we can," he claimed if the United States continues to support Kurdistan. "If we're on their side [the Kurds], we'll be on the right side."

Naab credits Kurds with knowing their neighbors well.

"Kurdish politicians are very clever. They know how to handle, they know how to deal in this snake pit ... [I've seen] for the past 26 years. But they can deal with it. I'm very optimistic about their ability,” he explained.

Garner believes nations who say they care about Christians are ignoring their plight in Iraq and not recognizing the Kurdistan Region’s sheltering of hundreds of thousands of Christians and other minority groups through the war with ISIS. 

"Iraqi Kurdistan has become a sanctuary for Christians. In 2003 there were over 1.5 million Christians in Iraq and now there are probably 300,000 left — or less. And most of them are here because they are protected here,” he said.

“I think the Western Christian community ought to realize that if they do not recognize an independent Kurdistan that there will no longer be a Christian element in this part of the region.



Muraz Adzhoev | 24/9/2017
It's time to take adequate measures against those, who are trying hard to disrupt the legitimate and justified self-determination referendum or at least prevent Kirkuk, Shingal and other Kurdish areas and territories from participating in it. All these opportunist provocateurs, irrespective of their party status and affiliation, must be brought to strict criminal responsibility for betraying the People, the Peshmerga, the martyrs, the future generations, the national history and memory and of course Kurdistan.
jake r | 24/9/2017
That's because Trump has an Ambassador here who is an Obama hold over, he is giving trump bad info, fire him and send somebody here who knows the score and can advise with some type of common sense..An American in ERbil..
FAUthman | 24/9/2017
Both Jay Garner and Richard Naab did a lot for the Kurds and they are great. Not that my opinion at all matters, but here is what think: I would go for confederation with assurances from the international community to expedite the resolution of all differences with Baghdad. But the referendum must be held tomorrow and it will be, because then if the guys in Baghdad do not live up to their commitments, Kurds can declare independence unilaterally and likely US and others would be on their side. Ex. US Amb James Jeffrey said it clearly : If Baghdad descends into chaos (and do not forget the Iranian influence) US would consider supporting Kurdish independence in Iraq. The disadvantage of that is: Kurds will lose the current momentum for independence (read ex French amb. Kouchner statements to Rudaw) and the Kurdish leadership will greatly disappoint the vast majority of the Kurds, esp the young, who want independence NOW! and I do not blame them.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Luigi | 9/20/2018 5:07:14 AM
Barham is pure ambition,opurtunism ,machiavilism and treason . He has betrayed both the PUK and the KDP. In the upkoming elections of September 30...
May God Save Kurdistan | 9/20/2018 5:21:20 AM
The chacal Barham Saleh has just retuned to where he belongs to : PUK, the den of traitors. PUK is sedition and treaon . Let's remind you the fact...
Twittersphere reacts with anger, hope, humour to Barham Salih news
| yesterday at 11:11 | (3)
Baaez | 9/19/2018 10:11:45 PM
After 20 years the Iranians barely agreed to the nuclear deal, which mildly restricts their production of plutonium for a while (not research and...
US open to talks with Iran: envoy
| yesterday at 09:06 | (1)
mark bishop | 9/19/2018 10:26:41 AM
Kirkuk's most loyal governor and supporter of Kurdistan, Najmaldin Karim of the PUK party, should rise up again and be selected as president of Iraq....
Kirkukly | 9/19/2018 5:33:09 PM
These two parties(PUK and KDP) brought no thing good for Kurds, but problems. No kurds voted for them and they cheated the election as usual. Iraqi...
KDP: No deal with PUK for presidency or Kirkuk governor due to constitution
| 18/9/2018 | (3)
Karwan | 9/19/2018 3:16:56 PM
This guy seems very desperate to obtain power. Jumping from one political party to another one. Why all that ego? How people can vote or trust him?
Dara | 9/19/2018 4:12:45 PM
So all the hotair about "a common kurdish stance" by KDP was empty talk as usual. I'm actually surprised that PUK nominated Saleh, he is a very good...
UPDATE: PUK nominates Barham Salih as sole candidate for Iraq presidency
| yesterday at 02:55 | (5)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Can Abdul-Mahdi or Alfayyadh ‘rescue’ Iraq if they are next PM? 11 hours ago |

Can Abdul-Mahdi or Alfayyadh ‘rescue’ Iraq if they are next PM?

"We need the next premier to be someone to rescue more
Iraq summons own ambassador to Iran for 'irresponsible conduct' to countrymen 12 hours ago |

Iraq summons own ambassador to Iran for 'irresponsible conduct' to countrymen

Iraqi foreign ministry expressed its anger over more
0.422 seconds