Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Mosul is 'going to get messy,' analysts predict

By Paul Iddon 13/10/2016
Iraqi Security Forces have arrived at the Khazir front, north of Mosul. Photo: AP video
Iraqi Security Forces have arrived at the Khazir front, north of Mosul. Photo: AP video
As the battle to force Islamic State (ISIS) out of Iraq's second city, Mosul, gears up analysts predict "it's going to get messy," pointing out potential coordination problems between the diverse forces arrayed against the militants.

Iraq analyst Joel Wing anticipates difficulties of cooperation between Iraqi Security Forces (ISF) and Kurdish Peshmerga forces which "could be an issue."

"The way cities have been assaulted before is to surround them, try to let civilians escape, and then begin the assault," Wing told Rudaw English. 

"In Mosul's case will the whole city be surrounded by the just the Iraqi forces or will the northeast be covered by the Peshmerga and the rest of the ISF?" he asked. "That could lead to some complications in the initial stages of the battle with coordination and communication." 

Kyle Orton, a Middle East analyst and Research Fellow at the Henry Jackson Society is also worried that there will be no "effective coordination between the various actors heading into Mosul."

"The recent outbreak of tension between Turkey and Baghdad, and by extension Iran and its militias, has done nothing to help this," Orton told Rudaw English. 

Presently the ISF are set to be the main ground force attacking the city with the Kurdish Peshmerga forces and Shiite Hashd al-Shaabi militiamen playing, at most, supporting roles outside the city.  

Turkey, however, is adamant that it will play some role in Mosul's liberation. The Turkish government has dismissed outright Iraq's demand that they withdraw the forces they have deployed to the Bashiqa training camp near Mosul. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan also insisted that, "After liberating Mosul from [ISIS], only Sunni Arabs, Turkmens and Sunni Kurds should stay there." 

"The Turkish proxy, Hashd al-Watani, was at one stage supposed to be a 'hold' force after Mosul's liberation, now apparently it's not going to be involved at all," Orton noted.  

The potential Turkish role in the operation is something Dylan O'Driscoll of the Middle East Research Institute (MERI) thinks could do serious harm to the delicate cooperative efforts of the other forces on the ground.   

"Militarily at least, the planning has not been lacking and there are clear plans for the operation with regards to the role of the forces, and coordination and command," O'Driscoll told Rudaw English. 

"The only unpredictable factor is Turkey and the level of their engagement, if any, will have a knock on effect on managing or controlling the role of the Hashd al-Shaabi, which could prove vital for the success of the operation and the post-battle stabilization," he added. 

Militias in the Hashd al-Shaabi, particularly those backed by Iran, are vehemently opposed to Turkey's presence in Bashiqa and have even threatened to attack them. 

One bizarre incident last December, when these tensions between Baghdad and Ankara began, saw the Kataeb Hezbollah militia claim on their television channel that they had been responsible for a rocket attack against Bashiqa which was attributed to ISIS. The claim was made in spite of the fact that, at that time, their forces were at least 100 kilometers to the south of that area.

Orton believes that any role played by the Hashd al-Shaabi in this operation could benefit ISIS. 

"Keeping the Hashd al-Shaabi out of the Mosul offensive is very important because its dominant factions, the sectarian Iranian proxy militias, as well as its human rights abuses against civilians, provide ISIS a perfect foil for recovery," Orton reasons. 

"At present it seems the Hashd will stay out, confined to areas west of the city. However, the Hashd spokesmen insist that their forces will be part of the operation, and the US has not pushed back very hard at this notion," he added.

Orton also believes that the presence of the Kurdish Peshmerga in the so-called disputed territories in Nineveh could alienate and embitter local Arabs; something he thinks may even benefit ISIS in the near future. 

"The Peshmerga is resented by Arab inhabitants for their participation in carving out a maximalist interpretation of the Kurdistan Region's border right after Saddam fell," Orton said.  

"So it's going to be messy. Mosul is another case where many actors are using the anti-ISIS fight to advance other agendas they've long sought, and in the process are setting up conditions that favour IS in the medium-term," Orton concluded.  

Comments

 
M Gonzales
M Gonzales | 13/10/2016
Tel Afar is going to be another interesting military engagement
Jews4Kurdistan | 15/10/2016
The Turkish Army doesn't have the stomach for this fight. They'll be keen to use Hashd al-Watani as a proxy. But when the going gets rough they'll withdraw to the safety of the KRG.
Mariam | 18/11/2016
It's too bad that Iraq gets treated with so little respect by Turkey. And, of course, NATO stands back and lets Turkey get away with it.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Brzoo Kurdi | 2/20/2017 5:56:21 AM
I just realized Islamic religion is not so bad , if you live in a jangle.but not in a civilized environment....
ISIS emir responsible for beheading 4 Peshmerga killed in coalition airstrike
| yesterday at 10:15 | (1)
Brzoo Kurdi | 2/20/2017 5:48:44 AM
Imagine , our neighbor,was not Turkey but France , was not Arab but English , was not the lunatics in Iran who dress like Arab , but German ,we would...
Barzani to arrive in Paris for meeting with French President
| yesterday at 08:40 | (1)
Brzoo Kurdi | 2/19/2017 10:51:44 AM
Abadi must stop listening to the ayatollahs in Iran and Iraq....
Brzoo Kurdi | 2/20/2017 5:10:38 AM
The unity of Iraqi Army , is next to Zero......the 2 factions , one represents the Pumpkin head Ali , and the other pumpkin head Mohammad or Omar ,...
LIVE UPDATES: Abadi announces start of military campaign for west Mosul
| yesterday at 11:48 | (4)
Karim | 2/19/2017 7:42:14 PM
Hi. We are kurd.all Kurdstan need be free.since 100 years. They. Trying killing as they did everything to our people. Home to home city to city land...
Nijyar Shemdin | 2/20/2017 4:13:55 AM
Congratulations on the successes of the KR meetings in Munich. One area of concern that leave KR shortchanged is the inclusion of the PMF or Hashd in...
Barzani gets support for right to self-determination in talks with world leaders
| 19/2/2017 | (10)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Iraqi forces face army of 1800 ISIS militants, 200 suicide bombers in West Mosul yesterday at 11:47 |

Iraqi forces face army of 1800 ISIS militants, 200 suicide bombers in West Mosul

The real fight will begin when Iraqi forces reach more
ISIS emir responsible for beheading 4 Peshmerga killed in coalition airstrike yesterday at 10:15 | (1)

ISIS emir responsible for beheading 4 Peshmerga killed in coalition airstrike

it was a joint operation between the coalition more
Kurdish conference brings four parts of Kurdistan together in Moscow 15/2/2017 | (20)

Kurdish conference brings four parts of Kurdistan together in Moscow

“the Kurds are one, and Kurdistan is one," more
0.188 seconds