Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

Can the United States stomach abandoning Iraqi Kurds again?

By Chris Johannes 3/9/2017
A young Kurdish girl holds US Army rations in 1991. The tents of the Cukurca refugee camp on the Turkish side of the Iraqi border are in the background. Joel Robine | AFP
A young Kurdish girl holds US Army rations in 1991. The tents of the Cukurca refugee camp on the Turkish side of the Iraqi border are in the background. Joel Robine | AFP
Western nations, namely the United States, have through public and official diplomacy stated they are against the timing of the Kurdistan Region’s self-determinative vote on independence that will be held on September 25.
 
A declaration of independence — if it ever comes — would of course force US decision makers to re-evaluate the one Iraq policy and the Strategic Framework Agreement, which has served as the backbone for diplomatic relations between Washington and Erbil via Baghdad for the past decade.
 
The West faced a similar choice after US President George H.W. Bush encouraged Kurds to rise up against the Baathist government in 1991 in the aftermath of the Gulf War. Bush then refused to arm the Kurds in the fight against Iraqi forces who were using aircraft to attack Kurds fleeing into the mountains by the millions.
 
"But I do not want one single soldier or airman shoved into a civil war in Iraq that's been going on for ages," he was quoted by The New York Times on April 13, 1991. "And I'm not going to have that."
 
Starving, freezing, and ill, thousands of Kurds died. Young Kurds under the age of 30 who now comprise about half of the population in the Region suffered malnutrition, if they survived. The Kurds were left to fend for themselves.
 
A study from the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) published in 1993 found that in the first two months of the 1991 crisis, children under the age of 2 “suffered significant” malnutrition. It added that “50 percent” of the children in its study at a camp in Zakho had generalized weight loss.
 
“The high rates of malnutrition and mortality related to diarrhea in infants and younger children of Kurdish refugees took place rapidly despite prompt relief efforts and a previously healthy population,” the study concluded.
 
The international community eventually responded by delivering emergency aid to refugees fleeing into neighboring Iran and Turkey. France, the United States, the United Kingdom, Turkey, and other states established the no-fly zone thereafter, passing a United Nations Security Council resolution to justify their actions, ending the Baathists’ aerial bombardments.
 
Economic sanctions were leveled against Iraq and in 1995 US President Bill Clinton’s administration backed the UN’s Oil-for-Food Programme aiming to provide food, medicine, and humanitarian necessities to all Iraqis, including Kurds in their de facto autonomous region.
 
Despite the program that ended in 2003, Kurds, just as they do today, maintained that Baghdad was not providing its share of resources. A 2005 UN committee found that the Baathist regime pocketed $1.8 billion during the program and about half of the 4,500 companies paid kickbacks to the government of Iraq to win lucrative contracts.
 
Although Turkey’s promise to not shut down the border after the referendum has assuaged some, there have been reports of people in the Kurdistan Region hoarding flour in anticipation of food shortages.
 

2017 is not 1991. Because of the Internet and social media, it takes just seconds for the world to see Kurdish news. Kurds are better recognized and their diplomats and emissaries from the Kurdistan Regional Government are welcomed nearly daily to see their counterparts in capitals across the globe, readily discussing politics, business, and humanitarian relations.

 
Are Western leaders such as the Americans ready to risk a humanitarian repeat of 1991, if the Kurdistan Region declares independence?
 
Kurdistan's champion of statehood is willing to press outsiders on how truly supportive they are.
 
"We would prefer to die of starvation than to live under the oppression and occupation of others. If this decision is made by referendum and the reaction is to isolate us, let our people die,” Kurdistan President Masoud Barzani told Foreign Policy magazine in June.
 
“That will be a ‘glory’ for the world that they have killed our people by starvation just because those people wanted to express their destiny through democratic means."

While not all people in the Kurdistan Region share Barzani’s indomitable view and still see some benefit in ties to Baghdad, the reality is that the ‘Yes’ vote is likely to prevail. That outcome and its subsequent negotiations will provide Western nations the opportunity to re-evaluate policy mistakes of the past.

 

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Khan | 3/9/2017
Can the United States stomach abandoning Iraqi Kurds again? Yes when it happened before it can happen always again. USA even supported Taliban I am sure they also created ISIS its their strategy to make war for their interests. USA also forced Russia to abandon Mahabad Republic USA fully supported Kemalist Turkey genocide against Kurds. Never blindly trust any country especially USA.
martin archer | 3/9/2017
Yes, the US can and will abandon the Kurds, particularly if they continue doing the US bidding without receiving anything of significance in return other than the usual empty promises. The Kurds would be well advised to conserve their ammunition and pull back from any lands then don't claim for Kurdistan. And to stop fighting ISIS and start fighting the Iraqi army wherever it is on Kurdish lands. Sooner or later the current crop of US generals will be replaced by commanders who have not lost their moral compasses and the new ones will abandon their naive efforts to restore the colonial borders of Iraq and Syria so that the Islamic despots they now support in Baghdad and the Ayatollah, Erodogan, and Assad can regain their powers. The US naively thinks that Turkey is an ally because it signed itself into NATO and hosts and airbase. It isn't. Its time to move the US airbase to Kirkuk and recognize the Kurds in order to reduce the power of the Islamic despots to cause trouble in the middle east. Anything less is a naive folly and doomed to fail.
yassir Al-Fekaiki | 3/9/2017
Question is not can they? but when? if it serves their purpose
Time for independence | 4/9/2017
Both the suject and the arguments are well articulated . Personally I believe the world will accept the Kurdish independence.
Publish Me Fam | 4/9/2017
They did that like a 100 times already and you still didn't learn your lesson from it. If Kurds had any kind of power in the middle east the Americans would stick to you like a leech, but you don't , you never did. In the past, Kurdish politicians sold the Kurdish people's rights for personal wealth and sadly they still keep doing it.
3642 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Slemani | 11/20/2017 12:39:41 PM
Dear Mr Barzani, with all due respect this type of taking only works when your opponent is a human being, all this civilised taking are falling on...
PM Barzani: KRG needs 'third party' help to interpret Iraqi constitution
| 14 hours ago | (1)
hate turkey | 11/20/2017 12:08:45 PM
There would be no IRAQ if the Kurds did not stand up to ISIS while your army RAN AWAY.
Referendum | 11/20/2017 12:29:02 PM
93%,,, This Micky Mouse Court going against Democratic Process of Voting and calling it illegal, How about the Fail of Mosul by Maliki or the illegal...
UPDATED: Iraqi Federal Court rules referendum 'unconstitutional', cancels its results
| 18 hours ago | (10)
Shaboom | 11/20/2017 7:14:49 AM
He must of heard oil it’s free now a days in Baghdad....
Love Kurdistan | 11/20/2017 9:09:59 AM
It would be his most stupid decision of his entire life. Becoming a citizen of Iraq to play in their national team. They are faking everything....
American basketball player becomes Iraqi citizen to join national team
| 19 hours ago | (2)
Kurdo | 11/16/2017 5:12:01 PM
Rudaw is blocking comments, you guys are just like press tv.
Masque du Furet | 11/20/2017 9:06:34 AM
Well, if I understand (a) It is not Barzani's fault of making an ill designed referndum. (b) it is not the US fault (did they spend the last 14 years...
Kurds shouldn't only blame America, Europe is a bigger accomplice
| 14/11/2017 | (23)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Qubad Talabani warns of existential threat facing PUK, Kurdistan 5 hours ago |

Qubad Talabani warns of existential threat facing PUK, Kurdistan

“Without a cohesive, strong and united PUK, more
Kirkuk Provincial Council chief postpones first meeting since crisis 6 hours ago |

Kirkuk Provincial Council chief postpones first meeting since crisis

Council member must feel safe and secure in more
Calm prevails though no real progress in ongoing Iraq-Kurd security talks: Minister 7 hours ago |

Calm prevails though no real progress in ongoing Iraq-Kurd security talks: Minister

ISIS is still present in some areas and makes more
0.343 seconds