Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

Towards an Iraqi confederation

By 8/10/2017
A young woman who voted in Kurdistan's independence referendum on September 25. Photo: Hejar Jawhar/Rudaw
A young woman who voted in Kurdistan's independence referendum on September 25. Photo: Hejar Jawhar/Rudaw
By Michel Wieviorka

The idea of nation is today readily associated with that of nationalism and hence with images of the worst excesses – right-wing extremism, racism, xenophobia, calls for closure and for ethnically or racially homogeneous societies. But this has not always been the case in history and recent referendums on the question of self-determination in Scotland, Catalonia or Iraqi Kurdistan have attested democratic demands far removed from the nationalist instincts which are the driving force of extreme-right voters and sometimes of the most extreme Far Right movements.

The case of Iraqi Kurdistan, perhaps more clearly than any other, deserves closer examination. This is a nation for whom the promises of the Treaty of Versailles, at the end of World War One, have not been kept. It is a population that has been subjected to massacres, gassing and all sorts of brutalities at the hands of Saddam Hussein’s regime. It is an organised quasi-state whose armed forces have played and continue to play a decisive role in the war against ISIS. It is a democracy that explicitly includes equality between men and women in its constitution and whose political system, despite many weaknesses, is no more in crisis than that of many Western countries. Who can do better than that, or as well, in the Middle East?

By organising a referendum which, like the one in Scotland and unlike the one in Catalonia, took place without conflict, the president of what is for the moment an autonomous region in Iraq, Masoud Barzani, may perhaps have had personal, collateral ambitions, a desire to retrieve his former position in Kurdistan at a time when it has weakened. But this is not the central issue. The main point is the massive number of ‘Yes’ votes in favour of Kurdistan’s independence.

Does this mean that the legitimacy thus acquired by those in power will lead them to declare independence in the near future? Definitely not.

Indeed, President Barzani has clearly indicated that he would now like to begin negotiations. It is not difficult to imagine what the next important stage in proceedings of this sort might be. In between the present situation, namely Iraqi federalism and the independence so longed for, it is in fact possible to conceive of an intermediary model of the confederal type and therefore with increased autonomy, which Iraqi Kurds might accept within the Iraqi state.

A scenario of this type would immediately come up against the Iraqi state. But this state is very weak. Without the Kurdish Peshmerga, it would never have been able to contribute to the downfall of ISIS. The reconstruction of Iraq could become a realistic project if it were to seek a negotiated agreement with Kurdistan.  The issue here is not one of dismembering a state, as could be perceived to be the situation in the case of the Catalan demands, but of the assertion of a Kurdish state on a confederate model within an entity which is for the moment in very bad shape.

The Kurdistan referendum has aroused negative reactions in many countries; only Israel has signaled its support. It is true that a state, instead of a Kurdish quasi-state, would change the geo-political situation in the region. But it is an error to see this as a source of reinforcement for other Kurdish demands, in particular in Turkey. Iraqi Kurdistan is a far cry from the PKK in Turkey.

It is urgent for the countries that bear the most influence on the course of events in this region to cease refusing to take Masoud Barzani into account. It is time for them to agree to support a process wherein a nation strives to put in place a state that is capable of contributing militarily to peace in the Middle East and of ensuring for its own population both democracy and respect for human rights. 

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.


Comments

 
Gerbert d'Aurillac | 8/10/2017
Well written. The Kurdish case for Independence is compelling, indeed .
Shkak | 8/10/2017
The establishement of a Kurdish state is the only hope that the West can actually have of a stable democratic and friendly country in that part of the world . An opportunity that should not be missed .Indeed, the U.S. must immediately reverse its actual negative approach, as rightly John Bulton , former American ambassador to the U.N., urges .
Help the Ezidis | 8/10/2017
The Iraqi confederatian existed already in practice before the referendum. Did it work? No. This idealistic model does not work, so I do not think that Kurdistan will try that again. The Kurds deserve an own state and yes the Iraqi - rest state is very upset which is a normal human reaction, but that is not the responsability of the Kurdish population.
truth | 8/10/2017
good idea if kurds were dealing with civilzed people and not criminals and traitors who hijacked iraq and the constitution
No Confederation | 9/10/2017
No talk of "confederation", please! We the Kurds are not interested in any shape or form to be politically associated with the Arabs, the Turks and the Persians. We are a 45-50 million people and deserve to have an independent country of our own. Period! Forget about "confederation"!
Post a New Comment
Comment as a guest or Login for more enhanced interactive experience

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Argushi, USA | 10/19/2017 9:47:07 AM
Wow this young men has made history. this is why the world respect kurds. but unfortunately when when we need the world they are no where to be seen...
Atsiravla Ekroy | 10/19/2017 2:19:56 PM
At least he stands for something!
Young man who defied police by taking down Iraqi flag: I was ready to die for Kirkuk
| 10 hours ago | (7)
duroi | 10/19/2017 1:58:33 PM
Baghdad will gradually implement all the anti Kurdish tested policies of Iran and the Kurds in Iraq are slowly sinking in this swamp because of ...
Iraqi PM orders arrest of security guards for violations in Khanaqin, State TV
| 6 hours ago | (1)
A. | 10/19/2017 11:33:42 AM
Has Iraq a court? wow what kind of justice do they have there? Lol! Shut uuup Iraqi bullshiters. /Sincerley everyone on this planet
Long live Kosrat | 10/19/2017 12:28:28 PM
God bless Kosrat Rasul, Iraq's high court should issue an arrest of Al Abadi for letting Hashed to loot, rape, murder and humiliate Kurds in Kirkuk,...
Iraqi court issues arrest warrant for Kurdish Vice President Rasul
| 6 hours ago | (7)
Darwin | 10/19/2017 12:22:01 PM
Really tragic how hatred can disolve all countries.. there is no point , just harrassing on the only damn planet we even see any sign of life. What...
Erdogan: Iraqi border may soon close on condition Baghdad meets KRG needs
| 7 hours ago | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

KRG welcomes initiative by Abadi for dialogue 2 hours ago |

KRG welcomes initiative by Abadi for dialogue

Abadi said dialogue is the solution to begin a more
Anfal survivor: My house set on fire following Iraq’s takeover of Khurmatu 3 hours ago |

Anfal survivor: My house set on fire following Iraq’s takeover of Khurmatu

I used to live in a small house in Khurmatu. They more
0.703 seconds