Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

What Israel's PM could have said

By DAVID ROMANO 14/9/2017
-
-

This week a statement from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu gathered much attention from Kurdish and other Middle Eastern media. Mr. Netanyahu said that Israel “supports the legitimate efforts of the Kurdish people to attain a state of their own.”

 

This is not the first time that top Israeli leaders, including Mr. Netanyahu, voiced their opinion on this matter. Coming in the midst of the growing excitement concerning Iraqi Kurds’ referendum on independence, however, the renewed statement drew added attention. The Prime Minister’s support also comes nearly a week after Yair Golan, Israel’s former Deputy Chief of Staff of the military, said at a conference in Washington that he personally does not view the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) as a “terrorist organization” and that a “solid stable cohesive Kurdish entity” in a “volatile Middle East” is “not a bad idea.”

 

Iran and many Arab and Turkish commentators immediately reacted to these statements by renewing their charges against the Kurds, accusing them of being “tools of the Zionists.” Many also accused Israel of extreme hypocrisy, given its military rule over Palestinians yearning for freedom and their own state.

 

By saying a bit more on the matter, the Israeli prime minister could have demonstrated exactly where the greatest hypocrisy lies. Several successive Israeli prime ministers from the Israeli Labour Party expressed their support for the establishment of a Palestinian state via the Oslo Accords. Even Netanyahu’s Right-of-center government likewise at least supports the principle of Palestinian self-determination – depending on its contours and how a final peace agreement with Israel would look like, this could mean a Palestinian state, incorporation of Palestinian areas back into Jordan or something else.

 

The Israeli Prime Minister could have therefore made a statement along the following lines:

 

“The Kurds in Iraq never engaged in terrorism. Unlike the Palestinians, they never hijacked civilian air planes, they never sent suicide bombers into restaurants, buses and old-age homes. They never threatened Baghdad, neighboring states or Arab civilians. Their leaders have pursued the most responsible and moderate of foreign policies, earning the Kurdistan Regional Government a lot of admiration internationally. While refusing to surrender their autonomous rights as enshrined in Iraq’s 2005 constitution, the Kurds in Iraq even undertook good and reasonable efforts to make the post-Saddam Iraqi state succeed. Its failure cannot be blamed on them.

“Yet the majority of the world strongly supports Palestinian self-determination. Even Israel itself supports Palestinian self-determination, and we look forward to a time when Palestinians choose leaders who do not glorify suicide bombers and pay their families stipends, or launch rockets at our civilian centers, so that we can make peace with them and help them realize their ambitions for self-determination [on this point, a more Left-of-center Israeli prime minister could even say “Palestinian state”].

“Why then is it only Israel standing up at this time to support a legitimate exercise in Kurdish self-determination?  Is Israel the only one lacking hypocrisy in this matter?”

In order to make life a bit easier for the Kurds, the Israeli leadership should also consider adding something else to their statements of support for Kurdish self-determination. It could be something along the following lines: “We support Kurdish self-determination because it is the right thing to do, and because it is in our interests to have more moderate, stable and hopefully friendly states in the region. We recognize, however, that the Kurds will always border Iran and Arab areas not at all friendly with Israel, and that they will need to do what they can to maintain good relations with these people. We do not for one moment, therefore, expect a Kurdish ally or “tool” to help us in our confrontations with such forces bent on our destruction. A friend, or at least not another enemy, will more than suffice for us.”

 

If one also considers that a distinctive Kurdish identity existed for thousands of years before a specifically Palestinian (as opposed to Arab) identity emerged, then most of the world’s hypocrisy on the matter becomes that more startling. Somehow the US State Department, Iran and others all think it the greatest sin to suggest incorporating Palestinians into Jordan or Egypt, yet they insist that the Kurds remain in Iraq.

 

David Romano has been a Rudaw columnist since 2010. He holds the Thomas G. Strong Professor of Middle East Politics at Missouri State University and is the author of numerous publications on the Kurds and the Middle East.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Miguel Servet | 14/9/2017
Compelling arguments , not heared before .
Miguel Servet | 14/9/2017
Compelling arguments , not heared before .
Guest | 14/9/2017
Good article.
The Kurdish Boy | 14/9/2017
Right now the U.S. is betraying the Kurds, after so much sacrifices they made fighting the I.S.The U.S. has no much moral superiority whatsoever than the I.S.
Kurdish State | 15/9/2017
The U.S. is siding with chauvinist Arabs,Turks and Iranians against the brave Kurds.McGurk and those behind him are not better than Saddam and Abubakr Albaghdadi . Curse on them all.The U.S. wants to appease its enemies by sacrificing Kurds.War is the ultimate judge between the Kurds and their ennemies.
Post a New Comment
Comment as a guest or Login for more enhanced interactive experience

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

pre-Boomer Marine brat | 10/20/2017 11:06:00 AM
The parallel with Austria on the morning of March 12, 1938, is not a good one. Czechoslovakia on March 15, 1939, is better. Likewise Poland. ... ...
anti jash | 10/20/2017 11:07:56 AM
peshmerge fought hard fierceful battle against hezbolla quds forces and hashd shaabi until they ran out of ammo and had to withdraw. IRANIANS ARE...
The bitter harvest of Kurdish divisions in Iraq
| 21 hours ago | (12)
John | 10/20/2017 11:00:21 AM
I am sure Trump sends his "thoughts and prayers."
Dan | 10/20/2017 11:01:46 AM
'He denied that the Iraqi forces are aiming to enter Erbil.' They shouldn't be trusted at all - they have been proven again and again that their...
Iraqi army, Shiite militia and Peshmerga exchange heavy fire north of Kirkuk
| 8 hours ago | (9)
Rogério | 10/20/2017 9:40:35 AM
we We hope they have a peaceful solution for the Kurdish.
Rogério | 10/20/2017 9:50:24 AM
Dialogue is the best solution. Kurds They are kind. fought against daesh.
Iraqi court issues arrest warrant for Kurdish Vice President Rasul
| yesterday at 08:38 | (18)
Louise | 10/20/2017 7:58:27 AM
I don't believe a word of it. There has been no statement from Johnson's office so the Iraqis seem to make it up. Their favourite subject seems to be...
abadi bad bad boy | 10/20/2017 9:18:09 AM
bullshioyt...this was planed with or without referendum. abadi the watermelon man very bad liar.
Iraqi PM Abadi talks with UK Foreign Secretary about Kirkuk
| yesterday at 11:55 | (7)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Iraqi army, Shiite militia and Peshmerga exchange heavy fire north of Kirkuk 8 hours ago | (9)

Iraqi army, Shiite militia and Peshmerga exchange heavy fire north of Kirkuk

Iraqi PM orders forces to stop at Kirkuk more
Kirkuk council won’t convene at ‘gunpoint:’ council head 10 hours ago |

Kirkuk council won’t convene at ‘gunpoint:’ council head

“I am the head of the council. I cannot go to my more
People of Kirkuk stage protest before US consulate in Erbil 16 hours ago |

People of Kirkuk stage protest before US consulate in Erbil

What is our sin? We just want to live more
3.359 seconds