Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Kurds shouldn't only blame America, Europe is a bigger accomplice

By Ayub Nuri 14/11/2017
Dozens of people from Kirkuk protested outside the US Consulate in Erbil on October 21, against the Iraqi army incursion into their city. Photo: Rudaw
Dozens of people from Kirkuk protested outside the US Consulate in Erbil on October 21, against the Iraqi army incursion into their city. Photo: Rudaw
Yes, Kurds felt abandoned and betrayed when the Iraqi army and militia groups attacked in mid-October, but I don’t think it is fair to only blame the United States. Some of the blame, or in fact most of it, must be put on Europe. They too had a moral obligation to stand by the Kurds. It is not in any universal constitution that only America should come to the rescue of others.

Europe has more at stake in Kurdish losses than the United States does. Had the Iraqi forces succeeded in entering the Kurdistan Region at least a million people would have become refugees and headed straight to Europe. Many of those internally displaced Iraqis, too, would have left the camps and joined the influx.

Europe is closer to the epicenter of Middle East events, including the Kurdish question in Iraq, and therefore any political disaster would affect them directly and in ways that may never affect America. Yet Europe continues to fail to act and asks the United States for help. And in most cases when the US does something they jump in with a long list of criticism and condemnation.

The Europeans are closer to the Kurds geographically. With many Kurds living in Europe and Europeans being in this part of the world for decades they are aware of the grievances and aspirations of the Kurds more than America is.

Why should the United States always be the one to intervene and do something? Europe too, especially France, Britain and Germany consider themselves world leaders and have the weapons, military, manpower and political and economic clout to do good.

The United States may be accused in some cases of indifference, as is now under Donald Trump. But at least in the case of the US business deals and money hasn’t always been at the center of politics as it is with the Europeans.

Europeans render their own democracy and rights of nations hollow as soon as they see a chance for selling cars or planes or the renovation of an oil refinery in the Middle East.

Europeans have a bigger share in the economic, political and social problems of this region. They were the ones drawing the maps of the Middle East and propping up dictators. They should not evade responsibility and rely on America to fix things.

When the Kurds of Iraq faced the terrifying prospect of losing everything to an advancing Iraqi army and militia groups last month, there wasn’t so much as a hiss of protest from Europe. They would have certainly held emergency meetings in Brussels if a million Kurdish refugees had shown up at their gates. And now with Kurdistan Region’s airports shut and new economic sanctions imposed almost on a daily basis Europe’s radio silence continues. Closing airports and banks and borders is as much about human rights as economics.

The Europeans betrayed the Kurds last month more than the United States did. The betrayal was not their failure to stop the Iraqi aggression. It was rather their rhetoric about freedoms and people’s right to choose their future, which somehow still manages to fool generations of oppressed people around the world.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.


Data pager
Page size:
COMMUNIST | 14/11/2017
the dilemma of primitive capitalism.....we all know the truth, we all see the truth, but we choose to believe in COSMETIC NARCISSISTIC LIES. freedom is only real when it is in your own hands.
Mike the Czech | 14/11/2017
The problem of author is that he thinks too much of Europeans and Americans and he is not in touch with the reality. Americans have only their geopolitical interests and the rest of it are tools how to get them. Europeans (and I am one of them), we talk. The more we talk the less we actually act. Action is hard and it brings responsibility. So we rather talk, especialy about the human rights because it gives us feeling that we are something special cause we incorrectly think that we brought them to the civilization. Look, you people in Kurdistan were at least able to vote during referendum. In Catalonia many people were not allowed to enter the polling stations or they were even beaten. The reality is that the people in Europe are loosing their rights and the more they will loose them the more their "representatives" will talk about them. And here is my advice: Get over internal disputes, get united, trust only yourselves and realize that you are alone. You won't get caught by surprise then. The rest take as a bonus: Find out what are American geopolitical interests in your region and ask Europeans what they can do and don't bother yourselves with what they say... Good luck Mike the Czech.
ken thomas | 14/11/2017
Cogently stated and perfectly true. The U.S. can do much more at no risk to itself.
Giuseppe geologist | 14/11/2017
Dear Author, in addiction to the true words of Mike the Czech, I can say that Kurdish people must reach autonomy first trough agricultural incomes - don't forget that you have water and a rich land - and trough the production non only trade. Trade give immediate money to singles persons and does not create wealth for the all people. Unfortunately, what I saw with my own eyes in Kurdistan Region is the failure of productive agricultural companies because "someone" (you know what I mean) earn a lot of money from transportation of Turkish and Iranian - also European - agricultural goods!
ARBIL | 14/11/2017
Post a New Comment
Comment as a guest or Login for more enhanced interactive experience
Tags :

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Muraz Adzhoev | 11/21/2017 11:02:49 AM
It is clear that they want to restore unity and integrity of the Iraqi (pro-Iranian) arab federation in order to “preserve” (autonomous) sovereignty...
duroi | 11/22/2017 5:25:35 AM
There is really no point in shuffling the cabinet which will last few months, a new minister needs several months to get settled and this also...
Gorran in meeting with KRG reiterates dissolution of government
| yesterday at 12:45 | (2)
duroi | 11/22/2017 4:59:58 AM
UNAMI needs to stick to its time limited "advisory and assisting" mandate and advise Iraq to withdraw from disputed areas its Iran backed militias...
Enkiu | 11/22/2017 5:08:59 AM
UN is an irrelevant and corrupt organization. UN ignores crimes or is ineffective in preventing them. UN takes no account of the quality of the court...
UN says referendum issue is resolved, urges KRG to accept court ruling
| yesterday at 11:49 | (10)
Outsider | 11/22/2017 12:24:07 AM
In the medium term, there are only 3 options: (a) accept the demands of Baghdad, (b) cooperate with Iran or (c) cooperate with Turkey. You are...
GUEST2002 | 11/22/2017 2:14:04 AM
what does that even mean?? why not fight the invaders instead?? why just give and give and give?? you gave the shiia jihadis 50 percent of your land...
PM Barzani: We agreed to Iraqi army territorial demands, but within limits
| yesterday at 09:04 | (5)
FAUthman | 11/21/2017 4:26:36 PM
Abadi's statements on the referendum were more reasonable than the those of the federal court: the referendum, Abadi said was no more than a public...
K | 11/21/2017 9:44:00 PM
Kurds ca never be independent by being a pussy. You should have fought to death for a few weeks and the world opinion about how serious Kurds are,...
Masoud Barzani: No court can cancel 3 million votes for independence
| 20/11/2017 | (16)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Boris Johnson: 'Serious effort' underway to bring Erbil, Baghdad to table 7 hours ago |

Boris Johnson: 'Serious effort' underway to bring Erbil, Baghdad to table

PM Barzani received a letter from UK FM, more
New Yezidi mass grave found in Shingal 11 hours ago |

New Yezidi mass grave found in Shingal

The mass grave contains the bodies of 73 people more
Rudaw’s field investigation into unknown armed group which emerged in Tuz Khurmatu 14 hours ago |

Rudaw’s field investigation into unknown armed group which emerged in Tuz Khurmatu

There are Kurds, Arab, English speaking people more
0.266 seconds