Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

America’s ‘allies’ in the Middle East

By DAVID ROMANO 19/6/2018
-
-
Two news stories in the past week shed light on some of America’s “allies” in the Middle East. The first comes from the disputed territories in Iraq – areas which Baghdad and its Iranian-allied Shiite militias recaptured from the Kurds in October 2017 as the United States stood by. In locations such as Tuz Khurmatu, Iran and its militias sponsored “al-Quds Day” (Jerusalem Day) rallies and parades. Besides the usual chants of “death to America” and “death to Israel,” the parades included American and Israeli flags painted on the road so that marchers and columns of (American-supplied) military vehicles would tread over them.

The second news story comes from Afrin in Syria, which has been under Turkish occupation since the spring of 2018. Turkish-allied Islamist militias in Afrin began a campaign to force women in Afrin to cover themselves in full burqas, claiming that such observance (to their interpretation of Sharia law) is “a red line” for them. Kurdish, Christian and Yezidi women of Afrin had become accustomed to the liberal and pro-women approach of the Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD) in the area. With the occupation of Turkey and its allied Arab-Islamist militias, however, efforts to impose extremely strict variants of Sharia law have replaced the liberal approach to social issues. 

This is occurring at the same time that some 170,000 Kurds have been ethnically cleansed from Afrin and prevented from returning there. Some 35,000 Arab rebel fighters and Arab civilians displaced from areas around Damascus are being settled in their homes to replace them. Citing the UK-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights (SOHR), the Independent newspaper in the UK reported that some of the Arab families, displaced from places like eastern Ghouta, insisted on paying rent to the Kurdish families whose homes they were resettled too – reasoning that just as it was wrong for the Syrian government to force them out of their homes, they did not wish to do the same to Syrian Kurds of Afrin. Turkey’s proxy militias would have none of it, however. 

“Ahrar al-Sham, a jihadi movement closely allied to Turkey, has evicted at gunpoint seven families of displaced people from eastern Ghouta, who had been living in houses in Afrin, because they insisted on paying rent to the Kurdish owners … SOHR says that Ahrar al-Sham has threatened to imprison the evacuees from eastern Ghouta if they return to the houses they had rented, on the charge of ‘dealing with Kurdish forces.’”

Reports of the abduction of women and girls, of Kurds being evicted from their homes and businesses, of attempts at the imposition of Sharia law, and of abuse of Yezidis in Afrin abound. Even the posters that the Turkish-backed Islamist militias put up in Afrin, telling women to cover themselves, seem eerily reminiscent of those the Islamic State (ISIS) erected in its areas of control.

These are the kinds of “friends” Washington has worked so hard to maintain its relationship with in the region. Although Baghdad did not organize the al-Quds celebrations in the disputed territories and Ankara did not sanction the hijab campaign in Afrin, both exemplify the general outlook of the current political leadership in both places. Countless other examples of visceral anti-American and anti-Western outlooks in both capitals, from conspiracy theories to extensive military dealings with Russia, exist. At the same time all this is happening, Kurdish parties in both Syria and Iraq remain socially liberal and pro-Western. They do their best to keep fighting ISIS and other enemies despite their lack of independent sovereignty and the limited financial and military means at their disposal. 

When weighing the value of allies, Washington and other Western capitals should therefore not only look at their relative power. By this metric, the Turkish and Iraqis states will always make more desirable friends than any stateless Kurdish party. The real question, however, should be whether or not the current governments – or likely future ones – in both Ankara and Baghdad can be friends of Washington at all. Have the policies and rhetoric of the last several years coming out of both these capitals given any real, enduring indication of partnership and affinity with the United States or Europe? How do these compare to the policies, rhetoric and genuine sympathies coming from various parts of Kurdistan?

In other words, it might behoove American and Western policy makers to engage in a serious reassessment of their Middle East policies, and to perhaps even think about coming up with a real “Kurdish policy” for a change.

David Romano has been a Rudaw columnist since 2010. He holds the Thomas G. Strong Professor of Middle East Politics at Missouri State University and is the author of numerous publications on the Kurds and the Middle East.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.


Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
123
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Jay | 19/6/2018
Thank you David for all the great insights and publications about the plight of Kurds. USA has never been a friend of anyone, it only serves its interests, they certainly have lost accountability in the entire world, the US has also lost control of the conflicts it is involved or started such as the conflict in Afghanistan and Syria; without doubt US facilitated the creation of Isis by supporting the Syrian opposition where Isis flourished. The US was funding the Syrian opposition ($500 million every 6 months), half of that money was going to Isis. Turkey on the other hand had the upper hand in opening its border to let Isis enter Syria and do business with Isis administration such as buying crude oil. Kurds on the other hand have no friends, because they are dispersed and refuse to reunite because the leadership only thinks about their own interests and ignore the interests of the Kurdish population, average Kurds also follow those ruthless leaders who take advantage. The other problem Kurds have is their faith, most Kurds are muslems and more faithful to their enemy's religion than they are to the Kurdish nation, since the days of Salahaddin Kurds have been used and abused by Arabs, Turks and Iranians and they have never learned their lesson. If Kurds had more loyalty to their ethnicity, they would have been an independent state by now.
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 19/6/2018
Might I suggest that the State Department is afflicted with a variant of Stockholm Syndrome? The condition is found in children who do not want to leave the security of childhood fantasies. It's also found in mothers who desperately mantain that the serial midnight slasher simply cannot be the child they raised. ... Foggy Bottom finds itself in a world it does not want to be in, and has become desperate over the past decade.
Non Kurd | 19/6/2018
Trusting Americans means you will be used and lose. If you dont learn lessons it will always continue.
Dawood | 19/6/2018
As if the Americans don't know how much Turks, Iranians and Arabs despise them. Kurds should learn to leverage the US to pressure Ankara Baghdad and Tehran to gain concessions and then drop the US. If the new Iraqi government for instance offers a decent deal to KRG like returning Kurdish territories (Kirkuk) resuming their full budget etc then they should take it, in return they would have to detach from the US but that's NOT a bad thing because the Untied States is not and never was serious about backing Kurds. Just look around, little by little, piece by piece the Americans are selling Kurds for other deals with Ankara and Baghdad, and even maybe Tehran, how much more proof do we need?
Dawood | 19/6/2018
Just to add another example certain delusional American analysts and officials were quietly celebrating the election results in Iraq because Sadr (the Shia cleric who's list got the most votes) was branded "anti Iranian". Now the same Sadr is in coalition talks with all the loyal Iranian factions in Iraq to form the new government. They forgot how much Sadr loaths the Unites States, his forces fought and killed American troops back in 2002-2007, he has never fought Iranians, he was rather pissed off at the Iranians because they supported other Shia factions more than him in the past. Now the Iranian regime will make him king of Iraq and don't be too shocked if he soon kicks out the Americans in Iraq. So a golden opportunity for Kurds to make a deal with Iran, get back Kirkuk and budget for going along with the new Iraqi government, if the Americans complain point to their countless recent betrayls both in KRG and Rojava and demand they officially declare support for an independent Kurdish state and back it up by concrete steps and maybe you might reconsider, they will of course do no such thing as was proven recently.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Gimle | 9/22/2018 1:05:30 PM
First Israel humiliate them by attacking several of their arms depots in Syria, killing dozens, and now this. All less than a month since the heinous...
Jamas | 9/22/2018 4:11:40 PM
Where are the big mouth Iranian trolls who were rejoicing the brutal attack on koya? no big words? Come on show us your 'mighty' Iran and try...
Gunmen attack Iranian military parade, casualties reported
| 19 hours ago | (8)
Gunrash | 9/22/2018 3:25:05 PM
Getting more and more respect for KDP. Aside from last year's events which showed who's patriotic and who's jash, KDP is showing it doesn't want to...
KDP won’t endorse Barham Salih for Iraq presidency, to nominate own candidate
| 10 hours ago | (1)
Hama | 9/22/2018 3:13:12 PM
Kurds under leadership of KDP and PUK need to prepare for a scenario in which a coalition will sideline kurds altogether. We should not count on...
Dawa leaders meet in first step towards Maliki-Abadi reconciliation
| 12 hours ago | (1)
Kosar | 9/22/2018 5:49:29 AM
Amazing fighter . I saw him on tv many times . He was a man that believed in Iraq and wanted to make things better . Wish more Kurds are like him .
shahab | 9/22/2018 2:58:59 PM
excessive exaggeration. if it was not for US air power, ISIS would have taken both Baghdad and Erbil. lets be honest
‘Legend’ Fazil Barwari, commander of Iraq’s elite forces, dies
| 20/9/2018 | (10)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

King Faisal II’s mountain palace – a lonely monument to Iraq’s traumatic past 4 hours ago |

King Faisal II’s mountain palace – a lonely monument to Iraq’s traumatic past

The young king was killed in the 1958 coup d’état more
KDP’s ‘unilateral’ Baghdad visit against spirit of Kurdish ‘unanimity’: PUK 5 hours ago |

KDP’s ‘unilateral’ Baghdad visit against spirit of Kurdish ‘unanimity’: PUK

The PUK and KDP had initially forced an alliance more
France: A central player in the fight against ISIS  6 hours ago |

France: A central player in the fight against ISIS

France has consistently proven itself in the more
0.391 seconds