Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





What the US needs to do now in Kurdistan

By Paul Iddon 24/10/2017
A protester beats on a gate at the US Consulate in Erbil as Kurds felt let down by the United States. Photo: Safin Hamed/AFP
A protester beats on a gate at the US Consulate in Erbil as Kurds felt let down by the United States. Photo: Safin Hamed/AFP
Residents of the Kurdistan Region presently feel let down, if not outright betrayed, by the United States and the Western world. Despite the sacrifices of their vaunted Peshmerga soldiers in the war against ISIS, none of these powers have done anything to help while the Iraqi military snatched up all their territories beyond the region's Green Line, most notably Kirkuk. Washington needs to act sooner rather than later to rectify this crisis. 

Invariably the US has said that it's allied with both sides, the Kurdistan Region and the federal government in Baghdad, and thus doesn't want to see them clash. The aggression perpetrated by the latter, however, cries out for a response. 

For one, the US should draw its own line along the Green Line that demarcates the autonomous Kurdistan Region from Iraq and openly declare that the US military is willing to enforce a defense against any Iraqi military incursions into any of Kurdistan's undisputed autonomous provinces – Erbil, Duhok, Sulaimani, and Halabja. 

US Apache attack helicopters operating out of Erbil International Airport were videoed hovering over the battlefield between Peshmerga and Iraqi Army/Hashd at Pirde (Altun Kupri) just south of Erbil Province's frontier with Kirkuk Province, on Friday. Washington should have no compunction about deploying such weapons to defend Kurdistan and its people from any attack. It could condition its support and guarantee of Kurdistan's continued sovereignty and security on the Peshmerga not advancing beyond the Green Line in an attempt to forcibly wrest back control of the territories. 

As analysts Michael Knights and David Pollack of the Washington Institute note: “This crisis is likely to damage US credibility, in Iraq and beyond, if Washington does not assertively and publicly demarche Baghdad at this point, and make demonstrations of military force – overflights, visible surveillance, observers on the Kurdish side – to show that 'enough is enough.'” 

This action should be a purely defensive one for a longstanding US ally against murderous Iranian-backed Shiite Hashd al-Shaabi forces that have the blood of Kurds, as well as American servicemen back in the days of the Iraq War, on their hands. 

Secondly the US should stop ignoring Iraq's usage of the Hashd forces with close links to Iran against Kurdish forces in the past week. Instead it should halt further delivery of all spare parts of US-made Iraqi military hardware, along with the remaining F-16 jet fighter-bombers scheduled for delivery to the Iraqi Air Force, until an honest and thorough investigation is done to determine if US-made M1 Abrams tanks were knowingly passed on to Hashd. Baghdad should be told in clear terms by Washington that action needs to be taken following the outcome of such an investigation if it wants continued support. 

Furthermore, Washington should also warn the conventional Iraqi forces that if any American arms are used against the Kurds in the future that will immediately waive the prior conditions under which the arms were sold to Iraq in the first place and result in penalties. 

Taking these steps could effectively freeze the conflict where both sides currently stand. While it will immediately disadvantages the Kurds, who've lost a whopping 40% of the territories they have a rightful claim to ownership over, it will nevertheless give them an opportunity to demonstrate that their claim to these areas is indeed legitimate under the constitution. Washington can then push Baghdad to first cancel its unrealistic demands from Kurdistan to begin negotiations and uphold the same constitution it has frequently cited in recent months and resolve the disputed territories issue through implementation of Article 140, or a new comparable alternative that includes censuses and referendums carried out in the areas in question.

There are already some reassuring signs that steps might be taken in this direction. In her statement on Friday's clashes in Pirde the US State Department's spokesperson Heather Nauert unequivocally affirmed that “The reassertion of federal authority over disputed areas in no way changes their status – they remain disputed until their status is resolved in accordance with the Iraqi constitution.”  

Washington could broker a comprehensive settlement between Baghdad and Erbil with international observers. Since it still wants to uphold friendly relations with both sides it could advocate demilitarized zones in these areas, save for some armed provincial police and security forces, which could serve as buffer zones between Iraqi and Kurdish forces similar to the demilitarization of the Sinai Peninsula in the Camp David Accords between Israel and Egypt just under 40 years ago. 

All of these options are far from perfect, but are nonetheless a whole lot better than risking more clashes and bloodshed.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.


Data pager
Page size:
Forked tongue | 24/10/2017
The US and Trump should pull the finger out. If the Kurds are left to rot, then the Shitites (shit of the Middle East) with Iran, Syria and Turkey will steamroll the equally Sunni shits of the Middle East and conflagration will occur - as has been done for over a thousand years. Arm the Kurds and fuck the Arabs - now then will be stability - provided the DOD Erdogan is nullified - rabid bastard.
Forked tongue | 24/10/2017
The US needs to acknowledge the Nation of the Kurds. Tell the Shitities and Sunni Arabs this is the defining moment - then define the borders of Kurdistan - easy, is it not. Ethnic lines are now drawn. Get some balls and trust the Kurds who have been betrayed. DONALD!!!!! are you listening????
duroi | 24/10/2017
This is the opportunity for US to destroy these American tanks and ancillaries and prevent the technology from falling into the hands of Iran. Iran will re-engineer and duplicate them and will discover their weak points which will undermine the defense of US allies, using the same technology. Trump must have terminated on day one the Obama's train and equip program which has provided the latest US military technology to terrorist IRGC through Baghdad. I think Iran has given a bloody nose in Lebanon to McMaster and other marine generals in the white house and they are still intimated by Iran to the extent of being very cautious and reactive which has crippled white house from developing a serious Iran strategy with Kurds who now feel betrayed by US. USA, Don't be a pussy ...
Kurdish State | 24/10/2017
Tillerson has asked Baghdad to implement Article 140 of the constitution. This way the Kurdish Independence will be assured .
Arkady | 24/10/2017
I am ashamed, we abandoned Kurds who believed that the US was their friend.
Post a New Comment
Comment as a guest or Login for more enhanced interactive experience

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Muraz Adzhoev | 11/21/2017 11:02:49 AM
It is clear that they want to restore unity and integrity of the Iraqi (pro-Iranian) arab federation in order to “preserve” (autonomous) sovereignty...
duroi | 11/22/2017 5:25:35 AM
There is really no point in shuffling the cabinet which will last few months, a new minister needs several months to get settled and this also...
Gorran in meeting with KRG reiterates dissolution of government
| yesterday at 12:45 | (2)
duroi | 11/22/2017 4:59:58 AM
UNAMI needs to stick to its time limited "advisory and assisting" mandate and advise Iraq to withdraw from disputed areas its Iran backed militias...
Enkiu | 11/22/2017 5:08:59 AM
UN is an irrelevant and corrupt organization. UN ignores crimes or is ineffective in preventing them. UN takes no account of the quality of the court...
UN says referendum issue is resolved, urges KRG to accept court ruling
| yesterday at 11:49 | (10)
Outsider | 11/22/2017 12:24:07 AM
In the medium term, there are only 3 options: (a) accept the demands of Baghdad, (b) cooperate with Iran or (c) cooperate with Turkey. You are...
GUEST2002 | 11/22/2017 2:14:04 AM
what does that even mean?? why not fight the invaders instead?? why just give and give and give?? you gave the shiia jihadis 50 percent of your land...
PM Barzani: We agreed to Iraqi army territorial demands, but within limits
| yesterday at 09:04 | (5)
FAUthman | 11/21/2017 4:26:36 PM
Abadi's statements on the referendum were more reasonable than the those of the federal court: the referendum, Abadi said was no more than a public...
K | 11/21/2017 9:44:00 PM
Kurds ca never be independent by being a pussy. You should have fought to death for a few weeks and the world opinion about how serious Kurds are,...
Masoud Barzani: No court can cancel 3 million votes for independence
| 20/11/2017 | (16)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Boris Johnson: 'Serious effort' underway to bring Erbil, Baghdad to table 9 hours ago |

Boris Johnson: 'Serious effort' underway to bring Erbil, Baghdad to table

PM Barzani received a letter from UK FM, more
New Yezidi mass grave found in Shingal 13 hours ago |

New Yezidi mass grave found in Shingal

The mass grave contains the bodies of 73 people more
Rudaw’s field investigation into unknown armed group which emerged in Tuz Khurmatu 17 hours ago |

Rudaw’s field investigation into unknown armed group which emerged in Tuz Khurmatu

There are Kurds, Arab, English speaking people more
0.454 seconds