Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





British MPs question Kurds on UK policy on Kurdistan

By GARY KENT 23/11/2017
The Foreign Affairs Committee inquiry into 'Kurdish Aspirations and the Interests of the UK' got off to a flying start this week with a major question and answer session with four Kurdish experts. 

They were Dr. Nazand Begikhani (Senior Research Fellow at Bristol University) Professor Mohammed Ihsan (Senior Research Fellow, King’s College London and former KRG Minister), Dr. Zeynep Kaya (Research Fellow, LSE,) and Guney Yildiz (Visiting Fellow, European Council on Foreign Relations).

The initial evidence-taking session sought basic facts about the Kurds. Ihsan described them as having a “forward-looking vision, not like some other nations in the area that are digging up their past and living in their past. I find them to be life lovers and freedom lovers, culturally.” He added that since 1991, “instead of looking to Tehran, Qom, and Ankara, they were looking at London, Paris, DC—a different, liberal point of view.”

Begikhani agreed the Kurdish “identity is based on culture... and that has made them open, tolerant and moderate, ready to embrace secularism and to integrate international human rights conventions, as well as gender equality.” She added that resistance is another defining aspect and includes Kurdistani women who “have very strong characters, despite the fact that the society is very traditional and patriarchal,” and have always been considered important actors in fighting, including against jihadists.

The Committee is studying aspirations in the four Kurdistans and views on a single Kurdistan. Ihsan said that Kurdish nationalism is fragmented: “We are brothers, but we are not partners in politics... We sympathise with Kurds in Turkey and Iran. We were thinking about big Kurdistan. The new generation thinks about a piece of Kurdistan.”

Ann Clwyd, the former UK Human Rights Envoy to Iraq, focused on internal Kurdistani issues. She expressed disappointment that the Kurdish Parliament has not met for two years. When corrected about the reactivation of parliament, which approved the referendum, she said it was “only for a few days.”

Yildiz explained events before the suspension of parliament in 2015 and that extremely high political fragmentation is the main obstacle to a united Parliament that can negotiate in a democratic environment. I would add, as one who once lectured half its MPs on the workings of the UK parliament, that the Kurdistani parliament is an asset but often sidelined by more powerful politburos, and that developing its expertise is a priority. 

Clwyd also raised women's rights and cited the incidence of FGM (female genital mutilation) as well as women but not men being charged with adultery. Kaya said women's rights in Kurdistan are better than Iraq thanks to legal changes after 1991, and that the KRG and policymakers “are, to an extent, genuinely trying to improve the situation but, in an institutional structure where certain practices have become very established, it is difficult to change, to turn legal changes into practice or make change on the ground.”

Witnesses also focused critically on the UK's reaction to the referendum. Ihsan said Kurds were shocked by the UK's silence since 16 October. Begikhani, who described the UK as “the midwife of the state of Iraq,” said Kurds were disappointed that the UK has been a “bystander,” rather than engage in preventing Iraqi army attacks, and stopping Iran in strengthening its bases, because “the Iraqi army would never have been able to do what it has done without the support of... Iranian-backed militia groups.”

She told MPs that “The UK should realise that this is going to lead to disaster, because the Kurds in Iraq now feel that they are taken as hostages by al-Abadi and by Iran. If we leave Iran to move further and to strengthen further its bases in Kurdistan and it weakens further the KRG, that will lead to further violence and religious and ethnic confrontation, not only in Iraq but in the whole Middle East...”

Begikhani urged UK mediation between Erbil and Baghdad and help to facilitate the return of over 2 million displaced people in Kurdistan. Ihsan said the totally untrue Iraqi excuse is they are implementing the constitution: “They are implementing corruption and power against Kurds and Kurdistan.” He appealed for “a truth-finding mission group to see what crimes have been committed in Taza Khurmatu and Kirkuk, which were not less than the crimes committed during Saddam Hussein’s time.”

Ihsan also argued that “A UK diplomat carries much more weight in these matters than any European diplomat, though not as much as a US diplomat.” It makes it essential that the UK fully understands events on the ground.

Earlier that day, Conservative MP Henry Smith asked a Commons question: “We have a lot to thank the Kurdish administration for, such as protecting minorities and its fight against Daesh in recent years. Will the Foreign Secretary speak to his counterparts in Baghdad to stop the intransigence of the federal Iraqi Government towards the aspirations of the Kurdish people for independence?”

Alistair Burt, the highly respected Middle East Minister, replied that “This has been a difficult recent chapter between the Kurdish region and Iraq. So far, because of good sense on both sides and a desire to reconcile, there has been no physical conflict at the border area. It is essential that both the Government in Baghdad and those in Erbil find a way through the present constitutional difficulties to make sure that the long-standing concerns of the Kurdish people are recognised within a united and strengthened Iraq. The United Kingdom will do all in its power to make sure we put our words to that effect.”

Maybe the minister's reference to the recent chapter refers to the period following clashes at border points, but there has definitely been violence. That seems to be over as Baghdad edges slowly towards dialogue with Erbil. But it underlines the importance of the FAC's detailed inquiry into events and how the UK might respond to Kurdish aspirations in the interests of the UK.

Gary Kent is the Secretary of the All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG). He writes this column for Rudaw in a personal capacity. The address for the all-party group is 

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.


FAUthman | 24/11/2017
One baby step at a time and Kurds will be up on their feet stronger than ever. That is because of the referendum and not in spite of !! The UN charter can then give them the right to self rule and Kurds can thus also get international recognition. Without the referendum that would not have been possible and Kurds would have been once again reduced to servitude and thrown into the waste bin of history with Baghdad becoming ever more aggressive! You wish to argue this point of view then go and do it with an expert like Peter Galbraith. For now, however get a working relations going with Baghdad and the neighbors to ensure payment of salaries and resumption of flights and a measure of stability, security and prosperity. Being part of a wealthy country like Iraq is not a bad deal and you may want to stay that way if good relations with Baghdad develop.
que sera sera | 29/11/2017
yes santa was early this year. prime minister may is in baghdad signing the execution agreement of peshmerga forces with iran.
Jay | 2/12/2017
May was in Baghdad to sell the tyrants in Baghdad weapons to use them against whoever they like including the Kurds. She also raced to sell weapons to SA to use them against Yemenis, as long as UK sells weapons and make money it doesn't matter how they are used. As for human rights and the rights of minorities, forget about them.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

pete | 10/15/2018 6:15:45 AM
Throw these prehistoric idiots into the sea. The World has moved thousands of years beyond them.
m | 10/15/2018 6:48:09 AM
what did Islam bring to Iran other than destruction since the Mullah's took over. If Islam is religion of peace, then how come there is destruction...
Islam can solve the Kurdish question: mullahs
| yesterday at 08:50 | (15)
Janelle | 10/15/2018 6:34:24 AM
INFRASTRUCTURE INFRASTRUCTURE INFRASTRUCTURE , have to climb mount Shingal, and scream it to the world, maybe only then will the twice dead wake...
Exclusive: Nobel winner Nadia Murad says Yezidis will return when Shingal is safe
| 9/10/2018 | (1)
North | 10/13/2018 10:00:54 PM
A huge humiliation for Erdogan and Turkey. Both Russia and the US used the same tactic and have demonstrated to the world that economical pressure,...
Fury | 10/15/2018 1:27:46 AM
Actually its a huge humiliation for.the usa since.the turkey alliance ever since has been a big
Pastor Brunson thanks Trump in meeting following Turkish court’s decision
| 13/10/2018 | (5)
Tron | 10/15/2018 1:24:31 AM
Hopefully winter will be always warm in Kurdistan
Syrian Kurds stock up on fuel for coming winter
| 13/10/2018 | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Ahead of Kirkuk anniversary, Sadr appeals for Kurdish-Iraqi unity 5 hours ago |

Ahead of Kirkuk anniversary, Sadr appeals for Kurdish-Iraqi unity

"We want you united, strong, and respected" more
Syria, Iraq say joint border crossing to re-open soon 6 hours ago |

Syria, Iraq say joint border crossing to re-open soon

"Victories against terrorism in Syria and Iraq more
Turkey to search Saudi consulate Monday: diplomatic source 8 hours ago |

Turkey to search Saudi consulate Monday: diplomatic source

"It is expected that a search will take place more
0.5 seconds