Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

The dangers of postponing the Hawija offensive

By Arif Qurbany 28/10/2016
-
-

 

Bypassing Hawija on the way to Mosul or postponing its liberation operation raises serious questions. I have been asking myself and other people about this. I hear that this is just a military tactic, that the liberation of Mosul will consequently force ISIS out of Hawija.


I do not find this convincing. There is a lot more than the obvious objective behind fighting ISIS, namely the struggle between the Sunnis and the Shiites, the rivalry among the warring factions, the problem between Erbil and Baghdad and their disagreement over the identity of the disputed areas, Baghdad’s effort to keep the Hashd al-Shaabi force operational, and other relevant matters. This indicates that bypassing Hawija is due to ulterior political motives, namely a pressure card on Kirkuk and Garmian.


The recent assault on Kirkuk confirms this reality. However, one of their objectives behind the attack was possibly to reduce the already increasing military pressure on Mosul, especially after ISIS realized that their defeat could only come at the hands of the Peshmerga, and that the Iraqi forces could not advance alone on Mosul.


ISIS wanted to change the balance of the war by attacking Kirkuk, possibly aiming to force the Peshmerga to withdraw some of its forces from the Mosul front to Kirkuk. Perhaps they also wanted to show the world that retaking Mosul is not that easy. If they could attack Kirkuk with a force of fifty militants, being able to stay there for two days, tens of thousands of militants can stay a lot longer in Mosul.


Postponing the Hawija operation is intended to undermine the Kurdish standing in the region, regardless of whether or not ISIS can put up a lengthy resistance in Mosul, i.e. whether they will fight to stay there or leave for Syria.


Even though I do not know the answer to the question of delaying Hawija, I have no doubt that this is to re-impose Baghdad’s hegemony on the disputed areas on the one hand, and to ensure that the Peshmerga do not end up being the sole hero of the war on ISIS, on the other.


But the Peshmerga’s push against ISIS over the past two years has shown the world how heroic the Peshmerga forces are in defeating ISIS. The Peshmerga liberated the majority of the disputed areas which were under Iraqi control before ISIS, and are now protecting them.


Baghdad wants to drive the Peshmerga out of these disputed areas, and does not want the Peshmerga to continue being seen as the hero in the fight against ISIS.


There is disagreement between Erbil and Baghdad over the future of these disputed areas after the demise of ISIS, with Erbil apparently insisting on keeping the area under Peshmerga control and Baghdad wanting to bring it back under the federal government by pushing the Peshmerga forces back to where they were before ISIS.


By postponing the Hawija operation, the Iraqi government wants to impose the participation of the Shiite militia in the liberation of ISIS-held areas and giving the militia legitimacy in governing them after they are freed.


The Iraqi government wanted to attribute the success of the war against ISIS to its army and the Hashd al-Shaabi forces, which is why they initially tried to exclude the Peshmerga from the Mosul offensive.


However, the Iraqi government eventually accepted the participation of the Peshmerga forces in the operation to recapture Mosul, and this was due to the indispensable role the Peshmerga have had in defeating ISIS in the region.


The Islamic State might transfer through Hawija its dispersed militants to Kirkuk all the way to Saadiya and Jalawla, so that the Shiite militia have a role in ejecting ISIS in these areas, diminishing the Peshmerga role in the war.


Kurds should bring the Hawija offensive forward or liberate the town concurrently with Mosul in order to avoid these eventualities.


The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.

Comments

 
duroi | 28/10/2016
Hawije is at the southern gateway to Mosul and any group dominant in Hawije can close the gateway and entrap the forces marching to Mosul. One hopes KRG make sure that Kurdish soldiers in Iraqi army and pishmergas do not sleepwalk into another military fiasco in Mosul worse than Mosul 2014, Faw and Karbala 4. Forewarned is forearmed.
General Dastan | 28/10/2016
You Kurds will get out of Kirkuk and Nineveh preferably peacefully but if not that way then forcefully.Do you think Iranians and Turks are carrots to see and watch that KRG annexes Kirkuk?PMU and Iraqi Arabs will come after you when they finish the job of ISIS.I love Kurdish blood Best Regards, General Dastan
KS | 28/10/2016
The author of this article was on the Ba'ath party payroll and is the definition of a jash.
bebegun | 31/10/2016
@General Hotair, as if threats have ever stopped Kurds, I'm not going to badmouth all Iranians and Turks but scum like you have tried that and much worse for well over a century, how has it worked out for you so far?. If there's only one thing you should've learned about Kurds by now is that you can NEVER intimidate or submit us, now come to Kerkuk with your imaginary army mr. internett warrior and see what happens
Tags :
3789 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

altani | 7/23/2017 4:46:13 PM
I don't care what happens in Syria, Iraq or Iran. However I do care what happens in Turkey. Turkey will never, ever be divided. I rather would have a...
Kobane-senah | 7/24/2017 4:11:39 AM
@Gerbert d'Aurillac Im kurdish american and love america however warn you put too much trust in amis politicians. Lets keep in mind our worst enemy...
KRG independence wouldn’t stir up separatism in other Kurdistans
| yesterday at 09:39 | (6)
FAUthman | 7/24/2017 2:19:58 AM
These guys need to lose some weight around their middle. With a pot belly like that as defense minister for Iraq and the other guy who is a spokesman...
Kobane | 7/24/2017 4:03:14 AM
Its disgusting all these bullshit of unity while no one asked kurdish people what they want. These full should know being poppets of big powers to...
Peshmerga to Iraqi defense chief: We defend ourselves in face of any possible threats
| 18 hours ago | (8)
FAUthman | 7/23/2017 12:44:31 PM
Looks like Putin is using Maliki to get the Americans out of Iraq when ISIS is defeated and to bolster Maliki to defeat Abadi in the forthcoming...
Jagerxin derashy | 7/24/2017 4:02:09 AM
If anyone is responsible for rise of Isis and fall of Mosul is you nori almaliki you treated sunnis like dirt and abused them!! you sad bastard if it...
Iraqi VP Maliki on official visit to Moscow, scheduled to meet President Putin
| yesterday at 02:00 | (2)
Bilal | 7/23/2017 11:02:00 PM
Shia Iran should just rename Iraq as a province of Iran its a vassel state of Iran at best not a nation partition is the only way forward.
History | 7/24/2017 1:26:23 AM
As much as I like Kurds to be independent country .. Turkey, Iran, Iraq and Syria will never allow it. Obviously to have freedom and respect the...
Kurdistan cannot secede from Iraq, predicts former PM Maliki
| 21/7/2017 | (13)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Journalists from Turkish daily face trial today 3 hours ago |

Journalists from Turkish daily face trial today

The 17 include reporters and administrators more
Army stays out of referendum dispute: Iraq defense chief 5 hours ago |

Army stays out of referendum dispute: Iraq defense chief

Iraq Defense minister: As for the referendum, the more
German girl who joined ISIS wants to leave Iraq, return to family 6 hours ago |

German girl who joined ISIS wants to leave Iraq, return to family

"I just want to go home to my family more
0.313 seconds