Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

Rojava’s Declaration of Federalism

By DAVID ROMANO 31/3/2016
-
-
On March 17 the leaders or Rojava’s three cantons – Kurds, Christians, Arabs, Turkmen and others – declared themselves a federal region within Syria. The declaration was unsurprisingly condemned by Turkey, Damascus, the Istanbul-based Syrian National Coalition, Iran and even the United States. An Assad regime officials stated that the move “has no legal basis and will not have any legal, political, social or economic impact.” Turkey made its usual dark warnings about never accepting a “terrorist entity” on its southern border. U.S. State Department spokesman Mark Toner announced that Washington “Won’t recognize any self-rule autonomous zones within Syria,” adding that “This is something that needs to be discussed and agreed upon by the relevant parties in Geneva and then by the Syrian people themselves.”

The Syrian Kurds were barred from the Geneva talks, of course, so it seems a bit ironic for American officials to demand that they discuss this with other Syrian groups and Damascus. Even more ironic is the fact that the Rojava leadership appears to be a more genuine reflection of Syria’s people – in all its diversity – than the Alawi Ba’athist regime in Damascus or the Sunni Arab, mostly Islamist Syrian opposition clients of Gulf Arab states and Turkey (never mind the “Islamic State” Salafis). Then of course we have further irony in that everyone knows autonomy and federalism are really Syria’s only option for ending the current civil war while remaining territorially intact.

At the risk of using the word “ironic” a few too many times, we should also marvel at a world where the Russians appear to be the only honest, straightforward diplomats in the room. While rejecting any a priori demands that Assad step down, Foreign Minister Sergay Lavrov said Moscow would support any solution that Syrians could devise together to end the war, including “any form of government whatever it may be called: federalization, decentralization, unitary state.” The Russians also appear to have few qualms -- in spite of opposition from Damascus, Iran and others – when it comes to helping the Kurds of Rojava advance their project. This has increasingly pushed the Democratic Union Party (PYD) into the arms of Moscow, where the group opened its first representation office abroad a short time ago. The PYD’s gains in Syria enrage Ankara, of course, which suits the Russians just fine. President Vladimir Putin seems ready to make his counterpart in Ankara regret shooting down a Russian jet last year for a long time to come.

According to officials in Ankara, Turkey’s worries stem from the PYD’s organic links to the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) with whom they recently resumed fighting. That much is understandable, as Turkey has its interests to pursue just like any other state. Unless Turkey resolves Kurdish disaffection within its own borders, however, problems will continue to fester with or without federalism in Rojava. Unfortunately, Turkey seems unlikely to reconcile its Kurdish population with a strategy based on laying siege to whole cities, endless curfews and its current political narrative and discourse. These things might be useful for concentrating more power in the government’s hands (or the hands of one man), but the Kurdish complaint in Turkey has always centered around insufficient democracy and human rights.

Recent statements from President Erdogan that "We do not want to see what is happening in Northern Iraq in Northern Syria" also convinces Kurds everywhere that the old Turkish chauvinism against them remains as alive as ever. The Kurdistan Regional Government of Iraq (which Turkey usually calls “northern Iraq”) is one of Ankara’s only remaining friends in the region, after all. Why wouldn’t Turkey’s leaders want to see more of that? If the Syrian Kurds were not led by the PYD, would Ankara be supportive of Kurdish autonomy in Syria? Probably not.

Ankara’s foreign policy lies in shambles in any case. Threats to invade Syria remain hollow, especially with Russian backing of Assad and the PYD. The grandiose dreams of just a few years ago, wherein Turkey was supposed to become the world’s 10th largest economy by 2023 or even a superpower on par with Russia and the United States, now seem like a bad joke. European Union membership will not happen no matter how many refugees Ankara threatens Brussels with. At most, Turkey may be able to crush the dreams of the Syrian Kurds, a goal which probably explains Prime Minister Davutoglu’s visit to Teheran after the declaration of federalism. Alternately, it may even be too late for Ankara to accomplish this.

As for the Kurds in Syria, they understandably do what they can to survive the Syrian maelstrom. Their declaration of a federal region is the most sensible thing to come out of that sorry state in a long time. It also serves as a reminder to Washington that they will try not be used militarily but ignored politically. Those days are hopefully over for the Kurds.

David Romano has been a Rudaw columnist since 2010. He holds the Thomas G. Strong Professor of Middle East Politics at Missouri State University and is the author of numerous publications on the Kurds and the Middle East.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Brwa Hamad | 31/3/2016
Well-written blog
Biji Kurdistan | 31/3/2016
Kudos for another great article Mr.Romano. Kurds in both Syria and Iraq have been taken advantage of for far too long, and the Kurdish people do not want to be divided, and they definitely don't want to fight for the interests of foreign nations. The foolish embargo between the KRG and Rojava should be lifted IMMEDIATELY, and both sides should work together to protect the Kurdish people from hostile regional powers.
Baran Kawa
Baran Kawa | 31/3/2016
Rojava should be part of Kurdistan Region of Iraq.
bebegun | 31/3/2016
"At most, Turkey may be able to crush the dreams of the Syrian Kurds, a goal which probably explains Prime Minister Davutoglu’s visit to Teheran after the declaration of federalism. Alternately, it may even be too late for Ankara to accomplish this" , yes that' what they're reduced to LOL, they went from superpower ambitions to being contempt if they can stop a small region like Rojava :). Remember they opposed KRG for almost 20 years, and they failed :). The tab on their current war on PKK is also piling up in the billions and PKK is just warming up
Mustafa | 31/3/2016
Any foreign power or neighboring country can always easily put Turkey back in it's cage by using the Kurdish card against them. Look at their pathetic desperation, running to Tehran and kissing Ayatollahs hands so that they might convince Assad to make a move against the Kurds, well aware of course that the whole thing is probably an Iranian plan to begin with. Turkey will never achieve anything close to it's potential as long as they haven't solved their Kurdish problem, they came close and it worried the whole region and beyond, too bad and too late now.
Tags :
7598 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

KRG | 5/26/2018 4:51:39 PM
No unity with a partys like kdp puk dividing Kurdistan.
Salim | 5/27/2018 5:09:32 AM
Its not possible I think
On party anniversary KDP urges Kurdish unity in dealing with Baghdad
| yesterday at 12:35 | (3)
Azad | 5/27/2018 2:21:11 AM
Clearly an ignorant lying individual who's clearly living in a different universe talking like she knows everything. We don't play by the rules of...
Hama | 5/27/2018 2:49:30 AM
This is what happens when an arrogant american works in Slemani and is brainwashed by Gorran fanatics. What's scary is not that she holds these...
Trump appoints KRG critic Denise Natali to top job – but who is she?
| yesterday at 01:14 | (7)
Yilmaz | 5/23/2018 10:18:09 AM
@Renas It's great to see someone on here who doesn't support the terrorist PKK. Respect for you. But Erdogan is a president of a sovereign nation and...
Guru | 5/26/2018 11:54:20 PM
Forget Erdogan he is the symptom not the cause. The cause is that all Turks are deeply rooted/ brainwashed fascists nationalists and terrorists but...
HDP: AKP is after our 80 seats but we will not give them away
| 22/5/2018 | (3)
Outsider | 5/23/2018 10:04:34 PM
Rudaw may want to publish also how many PKK fighters were (using Rudaw's term) killed since the Turks entered and in the immediate aftermath of the...
Guru | 5/26/2018 11:46:11 PM
Some dickheads in Ankara decide to attack and murder the Kurds and send their worst and poorest sons hoping those will die so they can have more of...
Two Turkish soldiers killed in PKK attack in Kurdistan Region
| 22/5/2018 | (5)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

PUK open for talks with all political parties: politburo 3 hours ago |

PUK open for talks with all political parties: politburo

"The PUK, right after the election, said we more
Iran officials stop deaf girls’ sign language song, say it resembles dancing 4 hours ago |

Iran officials stop deaf girls’ sign language song, say it resembles dancing

Dancing is outlawed in public spaces in the more
Russia forces among dozens dead in IS east Syria attacks 5 hours ago |

Russia forces among dozens dead in IS east Syria attacks

Moscow said Sunday four of its servicemen were more
0.219 seconds