Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





America's sad day of infamy

By GARY KENT 30/1/2017
Protesters opposed to US President Donald Trump's executive order banning citizens of seven Muslim-majority countries gather at New York's JFK airport over the weekend. Photo: AFP
Protesters opposed to US President Donald Trump's executive order banning citizens of seven Muslim-majority countries gather at New York's JFK airport over the weekend. Photo: AFP

Many feared the worst of President Trump while others hoped he would become more presidential. Such hopes have been dashed by his edict on "extreme vetting" that Times columnist Roger Boyes says is "the bluntest of blunt instruments, sledgehammer-politik."

The decree suddenly banned citizens of seven Muslim-majority countries from entering America for 90 days and suspended the refugee programme for 120 days. It was announced on Holocaust Memorial Day which reminded people of restrictions preventing Jews escaping the Nazis in the 1930s and ending up in death camps.

The countries are Iraq, Iran, Syria, Yemen, Somalia, and Sudan but not Egypt, Pakistan or Saudi from where bombers previously hailed. The ban includes those with visas, green cards, returning to their homes in America, or in some cases en route to America. The ban also encompassed maybe 250,000 dual citizens in the UK including Nadhim Zahawi, a respected British MP and citizen, who was born of Kurdish parents in Iraq.

Zahawi reacted in a dignified manner but his initial inclusion makes it a major issue for MPs and the Government. Quick footwork by Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson, who persuaded the American authorities to modify the presidential decree so it largely does not apply to British citizens, will slightly lessen the issue.

But expect more heartbreaking stories of family division, people being unable to visit dying relatives, start jobs while hundreds of Iraqi interpreters are reported as being in a visa limbo. Daesh must be rubbing its hands in glee.

The APPG last year highlighted an earlier restriction depriving British and other citizens who had visited several countries including Iraq/Kurdistan of their automatic right to enter the USA with an Esta travel document and to prove they were there on business approved by the US or to apply for a visa. This was a nuisance for those like me, my son and wife who must now go obtain a visa but it is small beer compared to the impact of the Trump edict.

Our fear last year was that this would chill investment as people found out that going to Kurdistan would complicate later visits to the US. International business groups have expressed fears that the latest ban will harm them.

No one denies that the US has the right to patrol its borders and to prevent terrorists from entering the US. But there is no evidence that current measures are failing or that a blanket ban is necessary.

It is astonishing that the move was made without consulting the State Department, which has a strong interest in increasing American soft power. Since the Cold War, the US has each year invited thousands on study tours to the US. I participated in a three week programme in 2002 which took me and a dozen journalists across the country to study how American foreign policy is made. We learned about America's rich pluralism of views.

Trump has in an instant damaged American soft power but we have also seen lawyers flock to American airports to give free advice, while an American judge has ruled that those with green cards and visas can enter. It is heartening to see American soldiers who served in Iraq standing up for interpreters who worked with them. We will see in the near future whether further changes can be made and whether the State Department can induce Trump to find a face-saving formula to rescind the order soon.

But relations and reputations has been harmed. One early victim is British Prime Minister Theresa May whose visit to see the new President has been, well, trumped by Trump's move. She did well in landing the possibility of a trade deal when the UK leaves the EU and showed great guile in trapping Trump into fully endorsing Nato.

It has also given a spring in the step to Opposition Leader, Jeremy Corbyn who was on the backfoot over Brexit issues and can now argue to acclaim that a formal visit by Trump should be cancelled. May and Corbyn's embarrassment and opportunity are neither here nor there compared to the misery inflicted on those who saw America as a sanctuary and a friend.

Trump will probably continue to govern in this disruptive, defiant and divisive manner and this presents big difficulties for America's allies. He may retreat after he has achieved his public relations aims and the former Foreign Minister, Alistair Burt, suggest that "you smack back quite hard in the first instance" to speed that up. Burt also suggested that a diplomatic excuse for postponing Trump's planned state visit to the UK in the summer might be wise.

We have seen the worst of Trump's America but also the best of America in the actions of lawyers, judges and people demonstrating for visitors and refugees. Trump may feel confident it will please his base, and he may be right for now.

Some prominent American conservative thinkers are disgusted. Professor Eliot Cohen, a former adviser to Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, writes in The Atlantic that: "Precisely because the problem is one of [Trump's] temperament and character, it will not get better." Cohen argues it will worsen as power intoxicates Trump and those around him, and probably end in calamity such as substantial domestic protest and violence, broken international economic relationships and major alliances, and one or more new wars, even with China. He would not be surprised if Trump is impeached.

More optimistically Cohen concludes that "There is nothing great about the America that Trump thinks he is going to make; but in the end, it is the greatness of America that will stop him." The ban may be further modified or lifted but leaves a lingering bad taste.

President Roosevelt described the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941 as a day of infamy. Trump's ill-considered and fruitless actions amount to a self-inflicted day of infamy for America and will long be remembered as the moment that pointlessly alienated America's allies and assisted its enemies. 


The Kurdish Boy | 30/1/2017
As a Kurd, I am a supporter of Trump, for whose fears I have full respect and understanding, yet I find this decree somewhat embaressing for me as it affects millions of innocent and decent citizens who symphatize with America.Most troubling is why the ban does not include citizens of Turkey who are lectured by their government everyday to hate America ?
The Kurdish State | 30/1/2017
Certainly Trump's decree is something to regret and will have lingering negative impact and much damage in terms of pain and suffer.Nevertheless,we Kurds have still a place in our hearts for Trump and America,and he can remain confident that his Kurdish friends are ex pecting him to unfold his policies to reverse the old and corrupt order of the leaders who preceded him.As from the old order we have only got denial and genocide that still goes unpunished.
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 30/1/2017
Mr. Kent, I too am opposed to Trump's executive decree. HOWEVER, I wish to most strongly object to your use of "day of infamy" to characterize it. ... My father was a serving US Marine on Dec. 7, 1941. You make Trump's administrative action equivalent to the murder of 2,000 men in an act of (as if happened) undeclared war. ... In my opinion, sir, your use of that specific characterization is despicable. Should you wish to hold to it, then in my opinion, you have opened your ideological kimono.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

guest2002 | 1/18/2018 3:44:37 AM
"mending relationship with neighbors" is like putting lip stick on a pig. it is more like cowering and kissing the behinds of invaders and bullies.
Yassir Fekaiki
Yassir Fekaiki | 1/21/2018 6:36:29 PM
mules of foreign powers remain as they are, mules
Kurdistan is mending relations with neighbours, says PM Barzani
| 17/1/2018 | (3)
Hawzhin76 | 1/21/2018 4:17:20 PM
YPG will understand that this is something different than taking a selfie in front of a Toyota pick up truck. Kurds follows wrong politics and they...
Soloist | 1/21/2018 6:25:02 PM
YPG are part of PKK and OCULAN they are a terrorist Group with a political agenda and manifesto. If you support the YPG then you are supporter...
Turkey launches deadly military operation against Afrin in Rojava
| yesterday at 11:59 | (35)
paraphine | 1/21/2018 3:19:39 PM
Turkey is also supporting and helping the jihad, radical islamist groups in the south of idlib province - which are fighting against assad and...
FAUthman | 1/21/2018 6:01:41 PM
"A main goal of the military operation (the Turkish offensive) was to recapture Tel Rifaat, a town southeast of Afrin, and a string of Arab villages...
Turkey continues its assault on Kurdish Afrin in Syria
| 10 hours ago | (7)
FAUthman | 1/20/2018 1:17:17 PM
That is right, Kobane was a turning point for Kurds and Obama made it happen when he came to the rescue of the Kurds in that city while Turks stood...
Smith | 1/21/2018 4:40:51 PM
WELL, WELL!!! I can see another fine mess the USA government are making for their country and it's people in another backlash like I would have...
Is Afrin worth a fight for the United States?
| 19/1/2018 | (8)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Kurdistan to deploy Peshmerga to help Afrin against Turkey if possible, PUK official 8 hours ago |

Kurdistan to deploy Peshmerga to help Afrin against Turkey if possible, PUK official

"If they allow us, we will deploy forces to more
Turkey continues its assault on Kurdish Afrin in Syria 10 hours ago | (7)

Turkey continues its assault on Kurdish Afrin in Syria

France calls for 'urgent' UN Security Council more
0.187 seconds