BAGHDAD, Iraq - A heavy silence fell over the Karkh Criminal Court in Baghdad as a screen inside the courtroom flickered on.
There appeared a young man dressed in black Islamic State (ISIS) attire, holding a Kalashnikov rifle.
He stood alongside two other militants as he wagged a threatening finger at France and the rest of Europe in aggressive French.
Yet, in the defendants' dock before the judge stood that very same young man dressed in an orange prison jumpsuit and thick socks.
This time, his head was bowed, his eyes fixed on the floor, unable to look at the screen for even a second.
Thus started the scene during Wednesday’s lengthy and detailed trial of the 15 French nationals charged with membership in ISIS.
Alongside the court officials, two representatives and an interpreter from the French embassy were in attendance.
Six of the group of French nationals were handed life sentences while the remaining nine cases were postponed until the end of this month.
The total number of French nationals convicted in Baghdad out of the 47-member group has now reached 16. The Iraqi judiciary has previously sentenced nine others to life and another individual to 15 years in prison.
The group of 47 French nationals linked to ISIS were previously captured by the SDF in northeast Syria (Rojava) Rojava and transferred to Iraqi authorities in September 2025.
Although all 47 hold French citizenship, only a small fraction are of ethnic French origin.
From investigative smiles to harsh verdicts
The defendants were brought into the courtroom one by one during Wednesday’s trial sessions. Wearing prison uniforms with unkempt hair and beards, the exhaustion of imprisonment was etched across their faces. During the questioning of the first nine defendants, the presiding judge spoke to them pleasantly, at times even smiling as he asked questions.
His demeanor took a dramatic turn when it came time to read the verdicts for the other six men. When several of the convicted men attempted to speak, they were denied permission and escorted out of the courtroom one by one.
Across the defendants' testimonies, one phrase was repeated continuously: "We were brainwashed and deceived."
Ibrahim Mohammed al-Khiyari: Threats in France, remorse in Baghdad
Born in Paris of Moroccan descent, defendant Ibrahim Mohammed al-Khiyari holds French citizenship and is on an Interpol Red Notice for charges of encouraging underage girls in France to travel to Syria. He joined the Sunni Islamist Syrian group, Jabhat al-Nusra in 2013 before becoming an ISIS militant.
In the courtroom, the judge played a video filmed in northeast Syria, showing Ibrahim holding a Kalashnikov and issuing fierce threats: "France, you are the first country we will liberate from infidels and disbelievers... We are aware of the planes you send over our heads in Syria to bomb us, and we will take revenge on you." In the footage, he also praised Mohamed Merah, the perpetrator of terrorist attacks in France who admitted to killing seven individuals.
In a low voice and with eyes full of remorse, Ibrahim said, "That video caused problems for my family in France, and my mother passed away out of grief over me."
Ibrahim recounted traveling to Syria at the age of 20, marrying two women named Sarah and Siham, and being "brainwashed" by their brother-in-law, Majid, who even forced his own sister to go to Syria.
He admitted working as a security personnel in Raqqa, the proclaimed capital of ISIS and in Aleppo also. He denied recruiting teenage girls and claimed he did not know the two militants standing beside him in the video.
Due to the complexity of his case, the judge postponed Ibrahim's hearing to November 26.
Cyril Jean Lopez: "I have forgotten my Arabic"
Born into a Christian family in France, Cyril was drawn to al-Qaeda in 2004. He studied Arabic in Egypt in 2009 and immersed himself in the works of prominent Islamic scholars such as Saleh al-Fawzan, Ibn Uthaymeen - two contemporary Saudi clerics - and Ibn Taymiyyah, prominent medieval Islamic thinker known for inspiring extremist movements.
When he stood before the judge and requested an interpreter, the judge laughed and asked, "Cyril, you spoke modern standard Arabic fluently in the previous session - why have you forgotten your Arabic now in Iraq?" Cyril replied briefly, "My Arabic is not good."
Known by the alias Abu Yassin al-Faransi, Lopez traveled to Syria in 2015 and worked for a monthly salary of $100 in the mechanical department of an ISIS factory producing reconnaissance and combat drones.
The public prosecutor demanded his conviction under Article 4 of the Anti-Terrorism Law because those drones carried mortar shells used to kill people. However, his court-appointed lawyer argued that because Lopez only worked on reconnaissance drones and committed no crimes in Iraq, he should be extradited to France. Cyril said quietly, "I am guilty, but I am deeply remorseful." The judge postponed his hearing to November 26 as well.
Domenico Giuberti: Suspected links to the France attacks
Domenico, an Italian, had previously used drugs in France before converting to Islam in 2011. In 2014, he traveled from Italy to Athens, before ultimately reaching Syria. He pledged allegiance to Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi and worked at vehicle checkpoints for a monthly salary of $175.
The gravest charge against Giuberti involved a mobile phone number.
Citing intelligence documents, the judge and prosecutor confronted him with evidence that he was arrested in possession of a phone number previously used by Abdelhamid Abaaoud - the mastermind behind the 2015 terrorist attacks in France that left 130 people killed.
Domenico denied having the number, saying in his final remarks, "I made a huge mistake in my life and left my daughter behind in France; I miss her very much."
His lawyer pleaded for leniency, and his session was postponed to November 26.
Rabie Mohammed: The ISIS paramedic
Born in Algeria in 1989, Rabie Mohammed Belkacem held a paramedic degree in France and owned a private internet business. He entered Syria via Turkey in 2015 and worked as a nurse in an ISIS medical center for a year and a half for $135 a month.
Confessing before the judge, he said, "Your Honor, from the outside I saw ISIS differently, the way it was advertised, but once I went inside, it was not like that." When the judge asked why he did not leave sooner, Belkacem replied, "Entering ISIS was easy, but getting out was very difficult."
Belkacem also apologized to all victims of ISIS. His lawyer similarly requested his repatriation to France, and his hearing was adjourned until November 26.
Abu Qudama: Accusing the investigative judge
Akim Oussine, known as Abu Qudama, is an Algerian born in Paris who learned Arabic in Egypt.
Unlike the others, he claimed he joined Ahrar al-Sham - a coalition of Sunni jihadist groups - in 2013 to fight against the ousted Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad's regime, but following the emergence of ISIS, foreign fighters were transferred into ISIS under an agreement between the two groups. He later worked in military depots in Aleppo.
Oussine stated that he left ISIS "out of conviction" in 2016 and never pledged allegiance to Baghdadi.
In a striking moment inside the courtroom, he accused the investigative judge of fabricating additions to his statement, claiming the judge told him, "Your file is too clean; it must be altered so we can sentence you."
The presiding judge immediately pushed back, noting there was no evidence to support the claim and that Akim's testimony contradicted his earlier statements. Following a brief exchange, Akim's trial was also postponed to November 26.
Other postponed cases included Anas Sulayman. Born in France in 1997 and of Djiboutian origin, Sulayman traveled to Syria in 2013 to join Jabhat al-Nusra before moving to ISIS. He married twice and earned a monthly salary of $50 within the group.
Sulayman noted that he tried to escape in 2016 but was caught, and was later captured by the now dissolved-Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) in 2019. His hearing was adjourned to November 26.
Ibrahim Khalil, a fair-skinned young man with a sparse beard, also had his case postponed. Born in 2000 and of Moroccan descent, he joined ISIS in 2014, and was captured by the Syrian Democratic Forces in 2016, latterly being handed over to Iraq. After being shown part of the evidence and expressing remorse, his session was postponed to November 26.
Abu Bakr Mohammed and Omar Amin were both summoned into the courtroom together, but an exhausted judge told them, "Honestly, we are tired and our interpreters are tired; your session is postponed to November 26."
When one of them tried to speak, the judge stopped him, reiterating that he was too fatigued to conduct their trial.
End of the session: Life sentences for six militants
In the final segment of the hearing, the courtroom shifted to issuing verdicts. Everyone in the chamber stood as six defendants were brought in one by one to hear their sentences.
Citing conclusive evidence, the judge handed down life prison sentences to Najib Fatmi, Noureddine Abdelkader, Thomas Kim, Abdou Mourad, Geoffrey F. Marcel, and Abdelkader Philippe.
Immediately after his sentence was read, Najib Fatmi called out loudly to the judge, "Your Honor, I want to serve my sentence in France or in Algeria." The judge replied curtly, "Leave that procedure for later; that is a matter for the government to handle."
The remaining convicted men appeared visibly distraught upon hearing their verdicts. The exception was Abdelkader Philippe, who bore intense anger on his face.
Following the sentencing of the six men, the two French Embassy representatives left the courtroom with expressions mixing disapproval and sorrow.

