Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Independent Kurdistan can be a factor for Middle East stability

By Paul Iddon 13/9/2017
People wave the flag of Kurdistan on Monday to show support for the upcoming independence vote in Akre, Kurdistan Region. Photo: Safin Hamed | AFP
People wave the flag of Kurdistan on Monday to show support for the upcoming independence vote in Akre, Kurdistan Region. Photo: Safin Hamed | AFP
The Kurdistan Region has consistently shown for years now that it stands as a factor of stability in the region and will continue to do so post-independence. 

A cursory look at the foreign policy to date of the autonomous region indicates that it has been quite accommodating with its neighbours. The Kurdistan Region today adequately lives up to the standards of the famous saying about the Kurdish people: they are like fire, if you approach them kindly they will warm you, but if you approach them aggressively they will burn you. 

Kurdish President Masoud Barzani has shown this to be true numerous times. In a recent interview in the Saudi press, the interviewer pointed out that Iran has major influence in Baghdad, Beirut, Damascus and Sanaa before asking Barzani if he feared Tehran would attempt to subjugate Erbil under its control. 

Barzani responded by first clarifying that Erbil does “not want to clash or enter a conflict with Iran” before warning that he will not permit his region to fall under foreign control. Simply put, any potential conflict between Iran and the Kurdistan Region would be initiated by the former. Iran is presently making more productive moves to increase its investments in Kurdistan.

The Kurdish president made similar statements about Turkey before the thaw in relations between them in 2009 (Turkey previously contemplated outright subduing Kurdistan's nascent autonomy in 2003, by sending up to 70,000 troops there as part of the American invasion of Iraq but opted out of participating in that war). 

When Ankara threatened to militarily intervene in Kirkuk, around 2006-07, on behalf of the Turkmen minority there Barzani hinted, after affirming that Turkmen rights in Kirkuk will always be preserved and respected under any Kurdish governance over that region, that his Region could respond in kind in Diyarbakir. Neither escalation transpired, primarily because Turkey didn't initiate it. Instead, Ankara has invested heavily in the Region and, in a twist that would be baffling to many less than a decade ago, the Kurdistan Region is in a sense the only neighbour with which Turkey presently retains good relations, in spite of its present stance against the upcoming independence referendum. 

This goodwill extends to Iraq, the very state from which the Kurds are working to secede. Barzani has stressed the independence referendum “will not affect the continued friendship and brotherhood between the Kurdistan and Iraq nations” but enhance it. 

The Kurdish president has routinely deemed post-2003 Iraq a failure, especially after former Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki's divisive and tumultuous tenure. However, the Erbil's decision to remain tied to Baghdad for the 14 years since the overthrow of Saddam Hussein shows their present endeavour is not a quixotic one done without giving a federal Iraq a chance to succeed. In this respect Barzani is correct, no longer will the Kurds feel bound to a country they don't identify with being a part of, but can instead deal with its southern neighbour on more equal, neighbourly and productive terms. 

The fear of Kurdish independence in the Kurdistan Region emboldening separatist Kurdish movements in Iran, Syria and Turkey is demonstrably exaggerated in light of Erbil's commitment to non-intervention in the affairs of its neighbours. Kurdish officials have reiterated this several times: rather than becoming a cause of further conflict in the Kurdish regions of the Middle East, an independent Kurdistan Region can become the solution to these conflicts and troubles, an arbiter that can help bring about solutions on mutually acceptable terms.

Denying the Kurds their fundamental right to hold a referendum and pursue their basic right of self-determination shouldn't be excused under the pretext that it is merely being done in order to preserve some vague stability, especially in a region where Erbil conspicuously stands out for its stability. Denying this right will likely prove a factor in causing further instability. Coming to terms with it, on the other hand, will more likely than not prove to be a factor in the stability of the small part of the Middle East in which this new nation will be born.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.



Herdem Kurdman | 13/9/2017
For the Kurds and for the world the best solution is the building one or four Independent Kurdish Countries. The USA,the Garant and the protector and Defender of human rights,dignity and freedom,will not be able to lead the world without solving Kurdish Independency Problem. The kurds need not live with their murderers. And USA know this and understand this more than any other countries in our planet. A kurdish state means being ally of USA and Israel in the brutal middle east and means supplying petrolium for the energy Need of civilisated world. Apart from these factes,Kurds will bring Democracy and stability in the Region. And after this The Chineses and Russians must discover a new middle east in our world!
Guest | 13/9/2017
Good article. I agree.
Kurdish State | 14/9/2017
Well written. It is obvious that the Kurdish territory is the only stable and secure place amid a region sinking in war and destruction . It is utterly cynical and indecent the way in which, under the fake pretext of stability, the powerful of this world deny the Kurds their right of voting on their future .
A Kurd in exile | 14/9/2017
Thank you Mr. Paul Iddon! God bless you!

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Cwthu | 10/21/2018 7:14:43 AM
This article doesn't reflect reality and appears to be old and not from October 2018 ... and oh by the way "this is the palace where mam jalal works"...
A terrified city: My first trip to Baghdad
| 13/10/2018 | (1)
Mamali Sha | 10/20/2018 12:52:23 PM
Of course they get away with it.These people attached to the picture own and run billion industries in north america, europe with access to deep...
Kurdo | 10/21/2018 1:46:53 AM
This mullah regime is over, follow the restart movement:
Iran hails victory over Trump after getting extension on financial reforms
| yesterday at 12:29 | (2)
Meil | 10/20/2018 9:30:38 PM
this statistics should be on picture (easier to read) and compare to previous election..
Election commission publishes official KRG election results
| 16 hours ago | (1)
Lemon_Kurd | 10/17/2018 3:54:53 PM
Best Friends with Bin Laden, Anti reforms in Saudi, Grandfather Turkish, Muslim brotherhood member/sympathiser, what a load of bollocks, thousands of...
Jim | 10/20/2018 9:25:06 PM
Which "friends" of Jamal's are you talking about. His old friends in the Muslim Brotherhood? He's more recent friends in Al-Qaeda? His buddies from...
‘Jamal never wanted to be called a dissident’: Friends of missing Saudi journalist
| 17/10/2018 | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Election commission publishes official KRG election results 16 hours ago | (1)

Election commission publishes official KRG election results

Coalition government expected as KDP wins 45 more
Gorran plans internal elections after parliamentary losses 17 hours ago | (3)

Gorran plans internal elections after parliamentary losses

“All the options are open before Gorran” more
Saudi account of Khashoggi killing is widely denounced 18 hours ago |

Saudi account of Khashoggi killing is widely denounced

Khashoggi's body has not yet been found more
0.5 seconds